Summary#
Bill 97, the Transparent and Accountable Health Care Act, 2022, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to promote transparency and accountability in health-care funding by applying existing accountability and disclosure laws to more organizations that receive public funds. The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.
- A person or entity receiving at least $1 million in public funds from the Ministry of Health in a fiscal year would be a “major health sector organization.” The bill gives examples including hospitals, long-term care homes, boards of health, and for-profit businesses.
- A person or entity receiving at least $1 million in public funds, directly or indirectly, from major health sector organizations or other publicly funded suppliers would also be covered. Payments for goods or services, fees for service, loans, and loan guarantees count.
- Covered organizations would be treated as designated employers under the Broader Public Sector Executive Compensation Act, 2014, and employers under the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996. The bill’s explanatory note says they would have to comply with those Acts.
- Covered organizations would be treated as governmental organizations under the Ombudsman Act. The Auditor General could audit any aspect of their operations, but would not be required to do so.
- The executive-compensation and Ombudsman rules would continue to apply after the first year an organization meets the $1 million threshold. Salary disclosure and Auditor General audit authority apply only in fiscal years when the threshold is met.
What it means for you#
- Health organizations and suppliers: If you meet the relevant $1 million threshold, the bill would make you subject to the specified laws even if you are not already covered by them. The actual duties under those laws are not set out in this bill.
- For-profit businesses: The bill expressly includes for-profit organizations. A supplier could qualify based on public funds received indirectly through other covered organizations or suppliers.
- Patients and the public: The bill does not directly change patient eligibility, health services, or fees. It creates wider accountability, disclosure, and audit coverage.
- The Auditor General: The Auditor General may audit covered organizations’ operations at any time during qualifying fiscal years; the bill does not require an audit of each organization.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill gives the Auditor General audit authority but does not provide an estimate of audit costs or additional staffing.
- Covered organizations may have costs to meet the requirements of the other Acts, but the bill gives no estimate.
- The bill does not set a tax, fee, fine, or appropriation.
What is unclear#
- The bill relies on the definition of “public funds” in the Broader Public Sector Accountability Act, 2010, but that Act was not supplied, so its definition could not be checked.
- The bill does not explain how to trace or calculate indirect payments through a chain of suppliers, or how the $1 million threshold would be verified.
- The text does not set out the detailed requirements imported from the executive compensation, salary disclosure, and Ombudsman Acts.
- The bill gives the Auditor General broad authority to audit “any aspect” of operations, but does not describe how audits would be selected or what process would apply.
- The supplied material does not state the bill’s passage status.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that public accountability should follow public money, including when it reaches suppliers through health organizations or other suppliers.
- Applying existing disclosure and oversight laws could make executive compensation and public-sector salaries more visible, and give the Ombudsman and Auditor General a wider role.
- The $1 million threshold limits coverage to organizations receiving a substantial amount of public funds.
Case against#
- The bill reaches for-profit businesses and suppliers that may receive public funds indirectly, but does not explain how far down a supplier chain the rules extend.
- The Auditor General may audit any aspect of a covered organization’s operations. The bill does not set out limits or a selection process for that power.
- The bill does not estimate the compliance or audit costs for organizations, suppliers, or government.
- The bill does not explain how its rules would interact with existing coverage under the three Acts.