Summary#
Bill 147 would enact the Protecting our Crowns (Training Requirements with respect to Black, Indigenous, Racialized, Natural and Textured Hair Types) Act, 2023. It would require the Minister of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development to update Ontario’s film and television safety guideline and make the new hair-training requirements mandatory for hairstylists in film and television and live entertainment. The bill’s stated goal is to address gaps in training and help Black, Indigenous and racialized performers feel safe and comfortable when their hair is styled.
- Within six months after the Act starts, the Minister must ensure Guideline No. 35 is updated to include training requirements for Black, Indigenous, racialized, natural and textured hair types.
- The Minister must ensure the updated requirements are mandatory for hairstylists working in the two industries. Those who already trained must meet them unless they show proficiency to Skilled Trades Ontario’s satisfaction.
- The Minister must consult specified communities, performers, hairstylists and educators when evaluating the updates.
- The Minister must consider options to make required training affordable and accessible. The bill does not require a particular subsidy or training program.
- The film and television definition excludes recorded sporting events, concerts and music videos, theatre, commercials, video games and educational material.
What it means for you#
- Hairstylists in the covered industries: You would have to meet the updated requirements, unless Skilled Trades Ontario is satisfied that you already have the required skills. The bill does not set out how to prove proficiency.
- Black, Indigenous and racialized performers and communities: Their representatives are among the groups the Minister must consult. The bill does not create a right to a particular stylist or a complaint process.
- Other hairstylists and the public: The requirements would not apply to hairstylists generally across Ontario under this bill. It also does not directly change hairstyling rules in the excluded production fields.
- Government: The Minister must update and make the requirements mandatory; this is not a new independent agency or a front-line service.
Money#
No cost estimate or funding plan is in the supplied material.
- The Minister must consider ways to make required training affordable and accessible, but the bill does not require government to pay for training.
- Hairstylists or employers may face training costs; the amount and who would pay are not specified.
- The Minister must supply the work needed to update the guideline and consult the listed groups, but no staffing or administrative cost is given.
What is unclear#
- The updated training content, when it would take effect, and how training would be delivered are not in the bill.
- The bill does not define “proficiency” or explain how a stylist would demonstrate it to Skilled Trades Ontario.
- It does not specify how compliance would be checked, or set penalties for failing to meet the requirements.
- The bill does not explain how training would be made affordable or accessible, or who would fund it.
- The current text of Guideline No. 35 was not supplied, so its existing requirements and how the update would change them could not be verified. The bill does not amend another Act.
Case for#
- The bill identifies a gap in hairstyling training for natural and textured hair and says performers have faced exclusion, injury and economic impacts. Updating training directly addresses that stated problem.
- Making the requirements mandatory could mean the new training applies across the covered industries, rather than only to stylists who choose to take it.
- Consultation with affected communities, performers, stylists and educators could help shape requirements around relevant skills and experience.
Case against#
- A mandatory requirement also applies to existing hairstylists unless they prove proficiency. The bill does not explain the proof process or how much time workers would have to meet the rules.
- The bill requires the Minister to consider affordability and access, but does not require funding or set a standard for either. Costs could fall on workers or employers.
- The bill leaves the training content and enforcement details to later work, so it is not yet clear what compliance would require or how it would be checked.