Labour standards expand platform pay rules

Summary#

The Working for Workers Four Act, 2024 is enacted Ontario law. It amends four existing laws: the Digital Platform Workers’ Rights Act, 2022, the Employment Standards Act, 2000, the Fair Access to Regulated Professions and Compulsory Trades Act, 2006, and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997. Its stated goal, as described by its title and long title, is to address employment and labour matters and other matters.

  • The government may set rules for platform workers’ pay periods and how platforms meet minimum-wage requirements; the Act itself does not set those rules.
  • It changes employment standards relating to trial-period training, job postings, tips, direct deposits, vacation pay and certain wage deductions. Some changes start only on a date set by proclamation.
  • It requires regulated professions to meet prescribed standards for fair qualification assessments, including assessments done by third parties.
  • It adds a workers’ compensation presumption for certain firefighters and fire investigators diagnosed with primary-site esophageal cancer, and lets the government prescribe additional increases to some benefit amounts.

What it means for you#

  • Digital platform workers and platforms: The government may prescribe limits on recurring pay periods and when paydays must occur. It may also set minimum-wage compliance rules, including rules allowing pay other than for each work assignment. The Act does not itself set the limits or rules. These amendments take effect only after the relevant parent-law provision has come into force and the Act has received Royal Assent.
  • Job applicants and employers: Once the job-posting provisions take effect, employers must not require Canadian experience in publicly advertised postings or related application forms, subject to prescribed exceptions. Employers using artificial intelligence to screen, assess or select applicants must disclose that use in the posting, also subject to exceptions. The Act’s text briefly adds a compensation-range requirement, then expressly repeals it; the enacted text therefore does not require pay-range information. Employers must keep postings and related application forms for three years after public access to the posting ends.
  • Employees and employers: Work done during a trial period counts as training for a rule in the employee definition. The practical effect depends on that definition’s other conditions. Three months after Royal Assent, employers must use permitted methods to pay tips and gratuities; direct deposits must go to an account chosen by and in the name of the employee, with access limited to the employee or someone they authorize. Employers sharing redistributed tips with themselves or a director or shareholder must post the policy and keep it for three years after it ends. Vacation pay may be paid using the specified alternative schedules only if the employee has agreed.
  • Workers and employers: The Act clarifies that a customer leaving without paying is included in circumstances addressed by an existing wage-deduction rule. The parent Act was not supplied, so the exact operation of that rule could not be checked.
  • Regulated professionals and applicants: The Act sets a basis for prescribed minimum requirements for fair qualification assessments, including requirements about contracts with third parties. The requirements themselves are to be set by regulation.
  • Eligible firefighters and fire investigators: The new cancer presumption applies only to prescribed workers who meet the listed work-history conditions, including at least 15 years in the specified roles, and whose cancer is diagnosed on or after January 1, 1960. It supports a compensation claim but does not guarantee an award; the presumption can be rebutted.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Regulations may set an additional indexing factor for certain workers’ compensation amounts; the Act does not set the factor or its cost.
  • The material gives no estimate for administration, benefit payments, employer costs or other financial effects.

What is unclear#

  • The job-posting rules, professional-assessment changes and workers’ compensation changes start on dates set by proclamation. The material does not give those dates.
  • Regulations still need to define publicly advertised job postings and artificial intelligence, and may set exceptions and conditions for the posting rules.
  • The government has not set the platform pay limits or minimum-wage compliance rules in the Act itself.
  • The prescribed standards for professional assessments, and how they will be checked, are not included.
  • The cost and size of any additional workers’ compensation indexing factor are not known from the supplied material.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so their full current wording and the exact interaction with existing rules could not be verified.

Case for#

  • The Act can give the government tools to set clearer pay timing and minimum-wage rules for digital platform workers without putting every detail in the statute.
  • Requiring disclosure of AI use and restricting Canadian-experience requirements could make some hiring practices more transparent and reduce one stated barrier for applicants.
  • Rules for paying tips and access to tip-sharing policies could make it clearer how employees receive tips and what an employer’s sharing policy says.
  • A cancer presumption could make it easier for qualifying firefighters and fire investigators to establish the work connection for a compensation claim.

Case against#

  • Several important protections depend on future regulations or proclamations, so the Act alone does not show when they will apply or how strong they will be.
  • The Act’s job-posting provisions do not require pay-range disclosure in the enacted text, despite briefly adding and then repealing that requirement.
  • The cancer presumption is limited by prescribed eligibility and a 15-year service condition, and it can be rebutted.
  • Additional benefit indexing may increase compensation payments, but the factor and resulting cost are not specified.