Summary#
The Keeping Energy Costs Down Act, 2024 is enacted as Chapter 10 of Ontario’s 2024 statutes. It amends the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998, giving the Minister, with the Lieutenant Governor in Council’s approval, new powers to direct some Ontario Energy Board (OEB) proceedings and decisions. Its stated goal is to keep energy costs down; the bill does not guarantee that result.
- The Minister may direct the OEB to hold a hearing on specified natural gas or electricity matters. The OEB must comply, and a directive may set timelines, procedures and information the Board must consider.
- Regulations may set a “revenue horizon” (the number of years of presumed revenue used in certain gas-system calculations). That horizon affects whether a new connection or capacity increase is considered economically feasible and any consumer contribution toward construction.
- For specified natural gas transmission lines, a directive may require the OEB to accept that specified gas consumers bear the full cost, while barring a contribution or surcharge from a gas consumer connected to or served by the line.
- The OEB must establish processes for input from electricity and gas industry participants and for representing electricity and gas consumers and other prescribed groups in proceedings.
- The OEB must grant an exemption from certain construction-approval requirements when prescribed circumstances are met. The Act also allows people to apply for permission to build some lines even if exempt from those requirements.
What it means for you#
- Gas and electricity consumers: The bill does not set energy rates directly. But directives, revenue-horizon rules and line-cost decisions may affect how certain costs are assessed or assigned.
- Gas consumers connected to specified lines: A directive may require specified consumers to bear the line’s full cost, but the OEB may not require a contribution or surcharge from a consumer connected to or served by that line. The bill does not explain how those provisions would work together in each case.
- Consumers and other prescribed groups: The OEB must create processes for consumer representation in proceedings. Regulations may require specified groups to be included.
- Gas and electricity industry participants: The OEB must create processes to receive advice and recommendations from the groups named in the Act, as well as any additional groups set by regulation.
- The OEB and Minister: The Board must implement approved directives. Directives may affect ongoing proceedings; in some cases the Board must set a matter aside from an ongoing case. The bill also removes procedural-fairness duties for these directives and related Board actions (such as notice, reasons or an opportunity to make submissions).
- Applicants for some gas lines: For orders made from February 22 to December 31, 2024, the Minister may direct the OEB to rescind an order refusing approval, or approving a line subject to a consumer contribution, and hold a new hearing. The bill does not create a general process to reopen other past decisions.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- The bill requires the OEB to establish input and representation processes, but gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
- Regulations or OEB decisions under the bill may affect the amount consumers contribute toward certain gas connections or capacity increases.
- For specified lines, a directive may assign the full cost to specified gas consumers; the bill does not state the dollar amount or how costs would be shared among them.
- The bill does not provide an appropriation, a fee schedule or an estimate of savings.
What is unclear#
- The available material does not include the full parent Act, so the existing rules and the full extent of the changes could not be independently checked against current law.
- The bill leaves key details to regulations and directives, including revenue-horizon lengths, prescribed exemption circumstances and which groups must be included in OEB processes.
- It does not define how “full cost” would be calculated or how costs would be divided among the gas consumers named in a directive.
- The bill does not set general application, decision, appeal or reporting rules for these new powers.
- The revenue-horizon section is set to be repealed on January 1, 2029, or earlier by proclamation. The supplied material does not say whether that repeal or other delayed provisions have since taken effect.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to let the government direct the OEB to consider specified energy matters on a common basis, rather than leaving them to separate proceedings.
- A revenue horizon could give the OEB a defined period of presumed revenue for assessing certain gas-system investments and consumer contributions.
- Required input and representation processes could give consumers and industry participants a formal way to offer advice and represent their interests.
- Allowing specified consumers to bear a line’s full cost, while barring contributions or surcharges from connected consumers, could be seen as a way to support construction without charging those connected consumers directly through those mechanisms.
Case against#
- The Minister’s directives can set hearing procedures and required evidence, and can override conflicting Board orders or other rules. This gives the executive significant influence over some regulatory decisions.
- The bill removes procedural-fairness duties for directives and related Board actions, including duties to give notice, reasons or an opportunity to make submissions.
- It is unclear how a directive assigning a line’s full cost to specified consumers would be reconciled with the ban on contributions or surcharges from connected consumers.
- Important details—including revenue horizons, exemptions and which groups must be included—are left to later regulations, so the practical effects are not fully set by the bill.