Public Sector Cybersecurity Bill Reshapes AI Rules

Summary#

Bill 194, the Strengthening Cyber Security and Building Trust in the Public Sector Act, 2024, would create the Enhancing Digital Security and Trust Act, 2024 and amend Ontario’s Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FIPPA). Its stated goal is to strengthen public-sector cyber security, set rules for public-sector use of artificial intelligence (AI), protect digital information about people under 18, and improve privacy safeguards.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council could make cyber-security rules for prescribed public-sector entities, including requiring programs and incident reports. The Minister could set technical standards and issue directives that covered entities must follow.
  • Regulations could require covered entities using AI to give the public information, create accountability frameworks, manage risks and meet other requirements. Rules could also prohibit specified AI uses. In some circumstances, entities would have to disclose information and ensure individual oversight.
  • Regulations and ministerial directives could set rules for prescribed school boards and children’s aid societies about digital information relating to people under 18 and technology made available for their use.
  • FIPPA would generally require institutions to assess privacy risks before collecting personal information, take steps to reduce those risks, protect the information, and report certain breaches to the Information and Privacy Commissioner and affected individuals.
  • The Commissioner could review an institution’s information practices and, after giving it an opportunity to be heard, order changes or other steps to bring them into line with FIPPA.
  • The bill text does not say whether it has received Royal Assent. The new Act and most FIPPA amendments would need to be brought into force by proclamation; the expanded customer-service-information rules have a different start rule.

What it means for you#

  • Public institutions, school boards and children’s aid societies: If prescribed, they would have to follow applicable regulations and technical standards. Entities receiving a cyber-security or under-18-technology directive would have to comply. The rules may differ by entity or category.
  • People whose information an institution holds: Institutions would generally need a written assessment before collecting personal information, including its purpose, legal authority, safeguards and risks. They must take reasonable steps to protect information and, in specified breach cases, report to the Commissioner and notify affected people.
  • People affected by a privacy practice: The Commissioner may review an institution’s practices and can order changes, including stopping a practice or returning, transferring or destroying information. The Commissioner may also decide not to review a complaint.
  • People dealing with a service provider organization: It could retain and use expanded “customer service information” to provide a designated service, but only with the individual’s consent.
  • The public: The bill does not itself set a list of covered AI uses, create an individual right to compensation, or establish a private-law duty of care. It gives ministers and the Lieutenant Governor in Council powers to make rules and, in some areas, issue directives.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill allows regulations to require programs, reports, assessments, safeguards and other work, but gives no cost estimate or staffing number.
  • It does not set a new tax, fee or fine in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • Which entities, AI uses and circumstances would be covered depends on future regulations.
  • The bill does not set the detailed content, timelines or oversight rules for many cyber-security and AI requirements; regulations would supply them.
  • Regulations may provide exceptions to privacy assessments and set other breach-notification circumstances. Those details are not yet in the bill.
  • The bill does not explain how new requirements would interact with existing programs or what resources institutions would need.
  • The supplied material does not establish whether the bill has become law or when its provisions would start.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address cyber attacks, privacy risks and the use of AI in public services by giving the government tools to set common requirements.
  • Requiring privacy assessments before collection could make institutions consider why they need personal information and how they will protect it.
  • Breach reporting and Commissioner reviews could help identify problems and require changes to practices.
  • Giving special rule-making powers for information about people under 18 recognizes that their digital information and technology use may need specific protections.

Case against#

  • Many important safeguards depend on future regulations and directives, so the bill itself does not show exactly what institutions or the public would have to expect.
  • The bill gives ministers and the Lieutenant Governor in Council broad authority to set requirements, while leaving many standards and processes open.
  • Institutions may face new work and costs, but the bill provides no estimate or funding plan.
  • The Commissioner may decline to review a complaint, and the bill says non-compliance does not by itself invalidate a decision or create a private-law duty of care. The text does not promise an individual remedy for harm.