Privacy bill would overhaul personal data rules

Summary#

Bill 14, Personal Information Protection Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law for how many private organizations collect, use, disclose and protect personal information. Its stated goal is to balance people’s privacy with organizations’ need to use information for purposes a reasonable person would consider appropriate, and to protect information when safety and security are at stake. The bill does not amend an existing Act.

  • Organizations covered by the bill would have to name people responsible for compliance, publish their contact information, maintain privacy policies and a process for complaints, and protect personal information.
  • As a general rule, organizations could collect, use or disclose personal information only with consent or where the Act allows it. The bill sets out exceptions, including for some investigations, emergencies, employment purposes and business transactions.
  • People would gain rights to request access to their personal information and ask for errors or omissions to be corrected. Organizations would generally have 30 business days to respond.
  • The existing Information and Privacy Commissioner would oversee the proposed Act, investigate or audit organizations, and make orders. The bill would also require the Commissioner to appoint a five-member advisory committee on law-enforcement requests for information held by private enterprises.
  • The bill would allow fines of up to $10,000 for an individual and $100,000 for an organization for listed offences. In specified circumstances, a person could also sue for damages for actual harm.

What it means for you#

  • Individuals: You could ask an organization for your personal information, how it has been used, and who it has been disclosed to. You could request correction of an error or omission. Some information could be withheld, including where disclosure would reveal another person’s personal information or create certain safety risks.
  • Customers and other people dealing with organizations: Organizations would generally have to tell you why they are collecting information from you. Some uses or disclosures without consent would still be allowed under listed exceptions. The bill does not require consent for every handling of personal information.
  • Employees and volunteers: An organization could collect, use or disclose defined “employee personal information” without consent when reasonable for establishing, managing or ending the work relationship. It would generally have to notify the individual beforehand, unless another exception applies.
  • Organizations covered by the bill: They would have to assign compliance responsibility, keep policies and complaint procedures, respond to access and correction requests, and take reasonable steps to secure information. The bill excludes, among others, public bodies, Ontario courts, and information covered by certain other privacy laws.
  • The Commissioner: The bill would give the existing office investigation, audit and inquiry powers, including power to require documents and enter an organization’s non-residential premises at a reasonable time. It would not create a new independent agency.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public or private costs is included in the supplied material.

  • Organizations would have to assign compliance responsibility and maintain policies and complaint processes; the bill gives no estimate of the staffing or other costs.
  • The Commissioner would have to establish and appoint a five-member advisory committee and carry out oversight duties. No funding or cost estimate is specified.
  • Organizations may charge a minimal fee for some access requests, but not for requests about an individual’s employee personal information. Regulations may set further fee rules.

What is unclear#

  • The materials do not establish the bill’s current status. If enacted, it would take effect three months after Royal Assent.
  • The bill does not define key standards such as what a reasonable person would consider appropriate. Regulations could add procedures and other details, but none are supplied.
  • The bill does not require the advisory committee to approve or review each law-enforcement request; it says the committee advises the Commissioner. How that advice would be used is not specified.
  • The bill excludes some information already covered by other privacy laws. Those laws were not supplied, so their current requirements and how the proposed Act would interact with them could not be verified.
  • The bill exempts the collection of personal information collected on or before its start date. The text does not make the full effect of that exemption clear, though it separately addresses later use of information collected before the Act takes effect.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give individuals clearer control over personal information held by many private organizations.
  • Requiring notice, security measures, access rights and correction requests could make organizations more accountable for information they hold.
  • A Commissioner with investigation and order-making powers could provide oversight when organizations do not follow the rules.
  • Allowing defined uses without consent—for example, in some emergencies or investigations—could let organizations act where seeking consent is not practical or permitted.

Case against#

  • The bill allows collection, use or disclosure without consent in many situations, and some exceptions depend on broad standards such as reasonableness.
  • The Commissioner’s investigative powers are extensive, including entry into non-residential premises and orders requiring people to answer questions or produce documents.
  • The bill sets duties for organizations and the Commissioner without estimating their costs or specifying how the work would be resourced.
  • The law-enforcement advisory committee’s role is limited to advising the Commissioner; the bill does not set out a required review or approval process for individual requests.