Bill would require free sexual assault kits

Summary#

Bill 20, the Access to Sexual Assault Evidence Kits and Provision of Sexual Assault Education Act, 2022, would amend the Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000 and the Public Hospitals Act. Its stated goal is to improve access to sexual assault evidence kits and education about sexual assault in nursing programs.

  • A person who grants nursing degrees under the post-secondary Act would have to offer Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner (SANE) training, free, to every student enrolled in its nursing program. If it did not, the Minister’s consent would be deemed invalid.
  • Each hospital would have to keep at least 10 sexual assault evidence kits available at all times and provide a kit free to any patient who needs one.
  • Regulations could define or clarify what “sexual assault evidence kit” means.
  • The bill would take effect one year after receiving Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Nursing students and degree-granting institutions: Students in a nursing program covered by the bill would be offered SANE training free of charge. The institution would have to provide that training or risk having the Minister’s consent deemed invalid.
  • Hospital patients: A hospital would have to provide a kit free of charge to a patient who needs one, and keep at least 10 available at all times.
  • Hospitals: They would have a legal duty to maintain that minimum supply and provide kits to patients who need them. The bill does not set out a process for deciding need.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill does not create a new agency or set up a separate program. It does require hospitals and covered institutions to provide services without charging patients or students.

Money#

The bill requires free training and free kits, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate.

  • Hospitals would have to obtain and maintain at least 10 kits and provide them at no charge; covered institutions would have to provide SANE training at no charge. The bill does not say how these costs would be funded.
  • No estimate of public spending, savings, or costs to hospitals or institutions is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000 and the Public Hospitals Act are not supplied, so the existing duties and how these changes compare with current law cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not define “sexual assault evidence kit” or “in need.” It would allow regulations to define or clarify the term “sexual assault evidence kit,” but no regulations are supplied.
  • The bill does not specify the training’s content, who would deliver it, or when students must receive it.
  • It does not set out how a hospital decides that a patient needs a kit, or provide rules for exceptions or oversight.
  • Whether Bill 20 became law: No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make kits available without charge and require hospitals to keep a minimum supply, which could reduce the chance that a kit is unavailable when a patient needs one.
  • Requiring free SANE training for every student in a covered nursing program could make that training available across the program, rather than leaving it to individual students to arrange or pay for.
  • Assigning these duties to hospitals and degree-granting institutions makes clear who would be responsible for providing kits and training.

Case against#

  • A fixed minimum of 10 kits at all times does not account for differences in hospitals’ needs or circumstances. The bill does not explain how the minimum was chosen.
  • “In need” is not defined in the bill, and it does not set out a decision process. That could leave uncertainty about when a hospital must provide a kit.
  • The bill requires institutions to offer training and hospitals to provide kits for free, but gives no cost estimate or funding plan.
  • The bill does not explain what would happen to a nursing program if the Minister’s consent were deemed invalid, or how that consequence would be handled.