Bill would require Sexual Assault kits in hospitals

Summary#

Bill 108, the Access to Sexual Assault Evidence Kits and Provision of Sexual Assault Education Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000 and Public Hospitals Act. Its stated goal is to address access to sexual assault evidence kits and education about sexual assault in nursing programs.

  • A person authorized under the post-secondary education Act to grant nursing degrees must offer Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner training courses free to every student in its nursing program. If it does not, the Minister’s consent is deemed invalid.
  • Each hospital must keep at least 10 sexual assault evidence kits available for patients at all times.
  • A hospital must provide a kit free to any patient who needs one.
  • The bill would allow regulations under the Public Hospitals Act to define or clarify “sexual assault evidence kit.” The bill itself does not define the term.
  • If enacted, the bill would come into force one year after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Nursing students: The degree-granting person must offer you the training free of charge. The bill does not say you must take or complete it.
  • People or institutions granting nursing degrees under the Act: You must offer the training to every student in the nursing program. If you fail to do so, the Minister’s consent is deemed invalid.
  • Hospital patients: A hospital must have at least 10 kits available at all times and provide one free if you need it. The bill does not set out how need is assessed or what other services must be provided.
  • Hospitals: You would have to meet the minimum stock requirement and provide kits without charging patients.
  • Current law: The supplied material does not include the two Acts, so I could not verify what requirements already exist or how these duties would interact with current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill would require hospitals to keep at least 10 kits available, but gives no cost estimate or funding source.
  • Nursing training must be free to students, but the bill does not say who pays to provide it or estimate that cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “sexual assault evidence kit,” though it would allow regulations to define or clarify the term.
  • It does not explain what makes a patient “in need” of a kit or set out a process for deciding.
  • It does not specify the training’s content, length, or how it must be offered.
  • It does not explain how the training requirement would be checked or what happens beyond the Minister’s consent being deemed invalid.
  • It does not say how hospitals would be funded to buy and maintain kits, or how the minimum would apply to hospitals of different sizes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make kits available in every hospital and require that patients who need them can receive them without charge.
  • Requiring training to be offered to every nursing student could give students access to education on sexual assault examination.
  • A minimum stock rule could help prevent a hospital from having no kits available when a patient needs one.

Case against#

  • A fixed minimum of 10 kits at every hospital may not reflect differences in hospital size or need, and the bill does not explain the cost or funding.
  • The bill leaves important terms and procedures open, including how need is determined and what the training must cover.
  • The bill requires training to be offered, but does not require students to take or complete it.