Municipal Integrity Rules Overhaul

Summary#

Bill 241, the Municipal Accountability Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s City of Toronto Act, 2006 and Municipal Act, 2001. Its stated goal is to change how codes of conduct and serious code violations are handled; it does not itself set out a new code. The schedules would take effect on a date set by proclamation.

  • Existing codes of conduct established by Toronto and other municipalities would lose force. The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations prescribing replacement codes and related requirements.
  • Ontario’s existing Integrity Commissioner would have new duties, including advising municipalities on request about an Integrity Commissioner candidate’s independence, providing prescribed training, and conducting a second inquiry into certain serious cases.
  • A local Integrity Commissioner could recommend that a council member’s seat be declared vacant only if the breach is serious, has caused harm to someone’s health, safety or well-being, and the existing penalties are insufficient. The recommendation cannot be made during the specified regular-election period or more than six years after the breach.
  • If Ontario’s Integrity Commissioner recommends removal, the municipal council must vote within 30 days. Approval requires every eligible council member to vote in favour. If approved, the member loses the seat and is disqualified from the specified municipal roles for four years.
  • The bill would allow regulations to set training, meeting, complaint and inquiry rules, and reporting requirements. It creates duties and powers for existing offices; it does not create a new independent commission.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal councillors and local-board members: If regulations require it, you would have to follow a prescribed code and take required training. In a qualifying serious case, you could face a second inquiry and a council vote on removal.
  • Municipalities and local boards: Their existing codes would cease to have force when the changes take effect. Municipalities would need to follow any new requirements made by regulation. A council may impose existing penalties if a matter is referred back; a local board may do so only if the municipality has not imposed a penalty for the same breach.
  • Integrity Commissioners: They would have new training and inquiry-related responsibilities. Ontario’s Integrity Commissioner must investigate a local commissioner’s recommendation and report back or recommend that the council declare the seat vacant.
  • Residents: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, benefits or municipal services. It could change how municipal code complaints are handled, but the bill does not require every complaint to be investigated.
  • Taxpayers: The bill assigns work to existing offices, but does not set out a funding amount.

Money#

The available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The bill assigns new duties to Ontario’s Integrity Commissioner and municipal Integrity Commissioners, but does not estimate staffing or operating costs.
  • No new tax, fee or fine is set out in the bill.

What is unclear#

  • The bill allows regulations to prescribe codes and many process details, but those regulations are not included. The bill does not itself provide a replacement code.
  • The supplied material does not include the full parent Acts. I could not verify all current inquiry rules, penalties or other effects against the law now in force.
  • It is unclear how complaints will be handled in practice, what standards will guide inquiries, and what information must be made public. Regulations may set some of these rules.
  • The bill does not estimate funding or explain how the new duties will be staffed.
  • The bill requires secrecy for information the Ontario Integrity Commissioner learns in these duties, and says that rule prevails over Ontario’s Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. The practical effect on access to information is not set out.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to create a more consistent approach to municipal codes, training and inquiry procedures across Ontario.
  • A second inquiry by Ontario’s Integrity Commissioner could provide an additional check before a council member is removed.
  • Removal is limited to cases meeting all the stated tests, including serious conduct that caused harm and where existing penalties are insufficient.
  • The election-period limits could help keep these recommendations from affecting a regular election campaign.

Case against#

  • Existing municipal codes would lose force, while replacement codes depend on regulations that are not included in the bill. The timing and content of those rules are uncertain.
  • The bill gives a route to remove an elected member and bar them from specified municipal roles for four years, but leaves many inquiry standards and process details to regulations.
  • A recommendation can pass only if every eligible council member votes in favour. That rule could prevent removal even when Ontario’s Integrity Commissioner recommends it.
  • The Ontario Integrity Commissioner’s new duties could require added resources, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan.