Summary#
Bill 68, the Modernizing Ontario’s Municipal Legislation Act, 2017, amends the Municipal Act, 2001, the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act and other laws. Its stated goal is to modernize municipal rules. It was enacted as Chapter 10 of Ontario’s 2017 Statutes, though some changes were set to start later by proclamation; the supplied material does not show which of those changes have since started.
- Municipalities must adopt codes of conduct and policies on council-staff relations, tree canopy and natural vegetation, and pregnancy and parental leave. They must also arrange for an Integrity Commissioner to cover the listed responsibilities, using another municipality’s Commissioner where needed.
- The conflict-of-interest rules add written disclosures, public registries and a ban on trying to influence certain decisions when a member has a financial interest. They also create an inquiry route through an Integrity Commissioner and expand the penalties a judge may impose.
- Municipalities gain powers to set administrative penalties for municipal by-law violations, subject to limits: penalties must not be punitive and must be no more than reasonably needed to promote compliance. A person cannot also be charged with an offence for the same violation.
- Municipalities may adopt environmental building rules within limits set by the Building Code Act and regulations, and may take part in long-term energy planning. The law also allows community councils with powers delegated by the municipality.
- The Act changes tax-sale timelines, including a 90-day process for certain Crown-owned land forfeited after a corporation is dissolved; allows qualifying municipalities to opt into broader investment powers; and changes municipal election dates and contribution limits.
What it means for you#
- Council members and school-board members: Pregnancy, childbirth or adoption-related absences of up to 20 consecutive weeks do not vacate a seat. School boards must also adopt pregnancy and parental-leave policies.
- Municipal and local-board members: A member who discloses a financial interest must file a written statement, which goes in a public registry. Members must not try to influence certain decisions about matters in which they have a financial interest. A judge may reprimand a member, suspend remuneration for up to 90 days, declare a seat vacant, disqualify someone from office for up to seven years, or order restitution in certain cases.
- People dealing with municipalities: A municipality may choose to impose an administrative penalty for a by-law violation. The bill does not set one province-wide penalty amount or create a detailed process for notices, reviews or appeals.
- Property owners and taxpayers: Tax bills may be sent electronically if the taxpayer chooses that option. Certain forfeited corporate land may be put up for public sale after 90 days if the arrears are unpaid and there is no extension agreement. The bill also shortens the general tax-arrears timeline before a municipality can begin a tax sale.
- Municipalities: A municipality may enter adjoining land, at a reasonable time and only as needed, to maintain or repair its own land; it may not enter a building under this power. Municipalities that opt into the new investment rules must follow the prudent-investor duty and diversify investments.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Municipalities must arrange Integrity Commissioner services and must indemnify Commissioners, and people acting under their instructions, for reasonable defence costs in certain good-faith proceedings. Staffing levels and costs are not stated.
- The bill permits municipalities that meet prescribed requirements to invest in any security under the new rules; it does not require them to opt in. Regulations may set further rules.
- The bill does not give estimates of administrative costs, savings, penalty revenue or tax-sale proceeds.
What is unclear#
- Several provisions were set to begin by proclamation. No publicly available information is provided here about which proclamations were made or when those provisions took effect.
- The bill leaves much of the administrative-penalty system to municipal choices and possible regulations. It does not set a standard hearing, review or appeal process in the supplied text.
- The rules for environmental building by-laws depend on Building Code provisions, conditions and limits to be prescribed by regulation.
- The new investment option depends on prescribed eligibility requirements and investment rules; those details are not in the supplied material.
- The material does not explain how the new powers overlap with existing municipal programs or how municipalities will involve residents in using them.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to strengthen ethics and accountability in local government through written disclosures, public registries, Commissioner services and clearer routes to investigate alleged conflicts of interest.
- Municipalities get tools to address by-law violations through penalties designed to promote compliance, without also charging an offence for the same violation.
- The environmental and energy-planning provisions give municipalities more room to address local concerns, while building-code rules remain subject to provincial conditions and limits.
- The investment option may give eligible municipalities more choice over how they invest money they do not need immediately, while imposing a prudent-investor duty.
Case against#
- Some important controls are left to regulations or municipal decisions. The bill does not itself set a complete penalty process or detailed safeguards for every use of the new powers.
- Broader investment choices could expose municipal funds to investment risks; the prudent-investor duty does not guarantee returns or prevent losses.
- The faster tax-sale process for certain forfeited corporate land gives interested people less time to pay arrears than the ordinary process.
- New duties—such as arranging Commissioner services and indemnifying them in some cases—may add municipal costs, but the supplied material gives no estimates.