Summary#
Bill 30, Fighting Back Against Handguns Act (Handgun Ammunition Sales), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Ammunition Regulation Act, 1994. Its stated approach is to let each municipality choose whether to prohibit the sale or provision of handgun ammunition within its boundaries; that choice is not required. The goal is to give municipalities this local option, not to guarantee a particular safety outcome.
- A municipal council could opt in by passing a by-law. If it does, no person could sell or provide handgun ammunition to anyone within that municipality.
- The prohibition would also cover online sales when the ammunition is delivered to someone inside the municipality.
- A person who breaks the prohibition could face a fine of up to $50,000 for a first offence and up to $75,000 for a later offence.
- The Minister could make regulations exempting a person or class of people, with conditions or limits. Before doing so, the Minister would have to prepare a report giving reasons and file it with the Legislature.
- The bill would start on Royal Assent. The parent Act was not supplied, so the existing law and how these provisions would fit with it could not be verified.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities: A council could choose to bring the prohibition into force in its municipality. The bill does not require any municipality to opt in.
- Ammunition sellers and providers: If a municipality opts in, you could not sell or provide handgun ammunition to anyone within its boundaries. The text expressly includes online sales delivered there.
- People buying or receiving ammunition: In an opting-in municipality, you could not buy or receive handgun ammunition there. This bill does not itself prohibit possessing or using ammunition, or selling handguns.
- Taxpayers: The bill does not set a tax or fee.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill sets maximum fines of $50,000 for a first offence and $75,000 for a later offence, but gives no estimate of how many fines might be imposed or how much money they might raise.
- It gives the Minister power to make exemption regulations but does not estimate the cost of preparing the required report or administering regulations.
What is unclear#
- The parent Act was not provided, so existing rules, exemptions, and enforcement arrangements could not be checked.
- The bill does not set out how a municipality would adopt or end an opt-in by-law, or whether any notice or public process would be required.
- “Provide” is not defined in the bill. It does not explain how that term would apply in different situations.
- The bill does not say what people or classes could be exempted, or what conditions or limits might apply.
- It does not explain how the new prohibition would interact with other rules that may apply to ammunition sales.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that municipalities could choose a restriction suited to local circumstances rather than having the same rule apply everywhere.
- Including online sales delivered into an opting-in municipality could make the local prohibition apply to those deliveries as well as sales made there in person.
- The exemption power could allow exceptions for specified people or classes, while requiring the Minister to give reasons in a report before making an exemption regulation.
Case against#
- A possible trade-off is that rules could differ between neighbouring municipalities, making it harder for sellers and buyers to know which rules apply.
- The bill restricts selling or providing ammunition within an opting-in municipality, but does not itself prohibit possession or use there. The scope of the restriction is therefore limited to the conduct it names.
- The bill allows substantial maximum fines but does not explain enforcement arrangements or how offences would be handled.
- The exemption power is broad: the bill does not name who could qualify or set out criteria for granting exemptions.