Deposit program bill aims to curb waste

Summary#

Bill 225, the Resource Recovery and Circular Economy Amendment Act (Beverage Container Deposit Program), 2024, would amend Ontario’s Resource Recovery and Circular Economy Act, 2016; it would not create a separate Act. Its goal is to establish a beverage-container deposit and return program as part of blue box collection.

  • Cabinet would be able to set detailed rules for the program and for collection depots. The program rules would have to require a deposit of at least 10 cents for covered containers of one litre or less, and 25 cents for covered containers over one litre.
  • The regulations would decide which beverage containers count as blue box material. The deposit and refund requirements would apply to those containers.
  • Grocery stores meeting the bill’s definition, and every store operated by Brewers Retail Inc., would have to act as return depots and provide refunds, as described in regulations.
  • Brewers Retail Inc. and each grocery store owner would have to ensure their stores comply. The bill makes failure to comply an offence.
  • If enacted, the bill would start one year after Royal Assent (the Crown’s formal approval).

What it means for you#

  • People returning covered containers: You would be entitled to the applicable deposit refund when you return a covered container to a required depot, subject to the regulations. The bill does not say which containers will be covered.
  • Grocery stores: A store would count as a “grocery store” only if it meets the bill’s tests, including having more than 4,000 square feet of retail floor space and meeting specified food-space and food-variety requirements. Qualifying stores would have to accept covered containers and provide refunds under the regulations.
  • Brewers Retail Inc. and its stores: Its stores would have to act as depots. Brewers Retail Inc. would have to ensure its stores comply.
  • The public: The bill does not set a tax, change who owns containers, or itself provide details such as depot hours or how returns are handled.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal information is in the supplied material.

  • People would pay deposits on covered containers and receive refunds when they return them. The minimum amounts are set in the bill; the regulations would identify covered containers and govern the program.
  • Grocery stores and Brewers Retail Inc. would have duties to collect containers and provide refunds. The bill gives no estimate of their costs or any public cost for staffing or administering the program.

What is unclear#

  • Which beverage containers would be covered, and what rules would govern returning them, are left to regulations.
  • The bill does not set out how depots must operate, such as how returns are handled or what hours apply.
  • The bill adds the compliance requirement to the Act’s list of offences, but the supplied text does not give a penalty. The parent Act was not supplied, so the penalty and the existing offence rules could not be checked.
  • It is unclear how the new depot duties would interact with existing collection arrangements.

Case for#

  • A deposit that must be refunded on return gives people a direct financial reason to bring covered containers back.
  • Requiring qualifying grocery stores and Brewers Retail Inc. stores to serve as depots could make return locations more widely available.
  • Minimum deposit amounts in the Act would set a floor, while regulations could provide the detailed rules for the program.

Case against#

  • The bill requires retailers to take on depot and refund duties, but gives no estimate of their costs or how those duties would work in practice.
  • The regulations will determine which containers are covered and much of the program’s operation, so important details are not settled by the bill itself.
  • The bill does not explain how the new depot requirements would fit with existing collection arrangements.