Summary#
Bill 230, the Housing Equity and Rental Transparency Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and Technical Standards and Safety Act, 2000. Its stated goal is to address rental conditions and improve transparency; that goal is not a guaranteed result.
- Landlords would have to keep common areas at 26°C or less from May 15 to September 15. Municipalities would have to investigate complaints from current tenants and issue work orders if an inspector finds a breach.
- In buildings with 100 or more rental units, landlords would have to install digital visitor-parking registration, video surveillance and security guards. They would also have to repair damaged or malfunctioning surveillance equipment within seven days after written notice.
- Landlords would have to provide tenants a paper guide to building amenities and an annual paper newsletter. Larger complexes would have to report maintenance-request statistics to a government portal each year.
- The bill would require rent abatements (rent reductions) in specified cases involving vital services, elevator outages and breaches of indoor-temperature work orders. It would also ban fees for visitor parking.
- Elevator owners would have to use remote monitoring. For outages longer than 24 hours in buildings with rental units, owners would have to report to the Technical Standards and Safety Authority; tenants could also report.
What it means for you#
- Tenants: If a vital service is withheld for more than 24 hours over three months, the Landlord and Tenant Board would have to order a 20% rent abatement on a tenant’s application. Periods caused by circumstances beyond the landlord’s control would not count. If an elevator is out for more than 48 hours over three months, the Board would have to order a 5% abatement on application.
- Tenants in larger buildings: Surveillance would cover interior and exterior common areas, including hallways and stairwells. Landlords would have to post notices, give prospective tenants information about surveillance before they sign, and follow regulations on handling footage. The bill does not set out those regulations.
- Tenants receiving rent through social assistance: A landlord could not use the specified ground of persistently late rent to end a tenancy if some or all rent is paid directly to the landlord under the Ontario Works or Ontario Disability Support Program laws.
- Tenants and landlords: Landlords could not charge tenants for visitor parking. Tenants could post a picture and comments about a maintenance request on the portal; landlords could post a picture as evidence that it was resolved.
- Landlords: Complexes with 10 or more rental units or at least three storeys would have to report maintenance statistics each year. If fewer than 90% of requests were resolved, the landlord could not apply for an above-guideline rent increase. The Minister would have to provide the portal.
- Other changes: For certain notices under section 50 about repairs or renovations, the bill would require a building permit to accompany the notice. It would delay some rent increases while a specified Board application is outstanding, and would change other rent-increase rules. The supplied material does not explain all the existing rules those changes affect.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the supplied material. No publicly available information.
- Landlords would face costs for required systems, security staff, repairs, guides, newsletters and reporting.
- Municipalities would have to appoint inspectors and investigate complaints. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- The Minister would have to provide a portal, and the Technical Standards and Safety Authority would receive and publish elevator information. Their costs are not stated.
What is unclear#
- The Residential Tenancies Act and Technical Standards and Safety Act themselves were not supplied, so the changes could not be checked against current law. In particular, the bill repeals an existing ground for an above-guideline rent increase, but the supplied text does not identify that ground.
- The bill uses “vital service” without defining it in the supplied text. It does not say how long the required rent abatements last or how overlapping abatements would work.
- Regulations would govern video footage, including when tenants could access or keep it. Those rules are not included.
- The bill does not set out detailed complaint procedures, timelines for municipal investigations, or oversight of security guards.
- Some provisions would start on Royal Assent, some 12 months later and others three years later. The bill does not give a calendar start date, and passage is not certain.
- The bill also changes rules for certain Board application fees and rent increases, but the supplied material does not explain the full context of those provisions.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address uncomfortable common areas, service interruptions and elevator outages with clear temperature limits and rent abatements.
- Requiring maintenance statistics could make it easier to see how quickly landlords respond to requests.
- Parking registration, surveillance notices and elevator outage reports could provide clearer records of activity and service problems.
- A security guard requirement in larger buildings could provide a designated person to patrol and respond to non-emergency complaints.
Case against#
- The requirements could add substantial costs for landlords, especially surveillance, security staffing and reporting. The bill provides no estimate of those costs or how they might affect rents.
- Surveillance would cover all common areas in qualifying buildings, but the bill leaves important privacy and footage-handling rules to later regulations.
- Municipalities would have to investigate complaints and appoint inspectors, but the bill provides no funding or required investigation timeline.
- The maintenance portal’s 90% threshold could block an above-guideline rent increase, but the bill does not explain how disputed or complex requests would be counted.