Summary#
Bill 25, the Rent Stabilization Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and Legal Aid Services Act, 2020. Its stated goal is to stabilize rent; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The supplied material does not say whether the bill has passed. If enacted, it would start six months after Royal Assent.
- Landlords would have to maintain rental units and buildings in good repair and fit for habitation. A failure would count as a breach even if the landlord had made efforts to maintain the property.
- A tenant could apply to the Landlord and Tenant Board without notice to the landlord if work required by a mediated settlement or prior Board order was not completed on time. The Board could order a daily fine of up to $1,000, reduce rent, or both.
- The bill would set limits on rent charged to new tenants, based on the unit’s prior lawful rent and the time since it was last rented.
- The Board would have to create a registry for covered rental units. Landlords would have to file rent and other information, and the public could see unit addresses and rent amounts.
- The Legal Aid Services Corporation would have to provide legal representation to tenants who request it and are directly affected by an application to raise rent above the guideline. No usual eligibility test or contribution could be required for this service.
What it means for you#
- Landlords: You would have to file a statement within 30 days of entering a lease, update rent information within 30 days of a rent change, and give the tenant copies. A landlord who has not filed the statement could not increase rent for that unit. The bill also makes failing to file, and filing false information, offences; it does not state the penalties.
- Tenants: You could challenge the accuracy of information about your unit within 60 days of receiving a statement or rent-change notice. If the Board finds you were charged more than the lawful rent, it would have to order the landlord to repay the excess.
- Tenants facing an above-guideline increase application: If you request legal representation, the Legal Aid Services Corporation would have to provide it. The bill removes the usual eligibility conditions and any required contribution for this representation.
- Prospective tenants and the public: You could request registry information about a specific unit if you have applied to rent it. The public could view unit addresses and rents, including the effective dates of rent changes.
- Landlords and tenants: The bill would also change when a landlord can take a rent increase after certain repair-related orders. The landlord would first have to complete the specified work.
Money#
The bill requires registry administration and legal representation, but no cost estimate is available.
- The Board would have to create and maintain the registry and take reasonable steps to keep its information accurate.
- Legal aid would have to provide the specified representation without applying normal eligibility conditions or requiring contributions.
- The Board could order landlords to pay administrative fines of up to $1,000 per day for failure to complete specified work. The money would be paid to the Board.
- No funding amount, staffing estimate, or expected fine revenue is provided.
What is unclear#
- The Residential Tenancies Act itself was not supplied, so the bill’s changes cannot be fully compared with current law, including the precise effect of changes to the Act’s exemptions and other rent rules.
- The bill leaves some registry information to be set later by regulation. It does not set out all registry procedures or how the Board will verify information.
- The bill does not state the penalties for the new offences of failing to file or filing false information.
- The bill does not explain how the Board will apply the new rent rules in all cases or how they interact with other existing programs.
- The current status of the bill is not provided.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make landlords answerable when required repairs remain incomplete, with rent reductions and daily fines among the Board’s possible tools.
- A public record of unit rents could give tenants and prospective tenants a way to check rent information.
- Limiting new-tenant rent by reference to prior lawful rent could make it harder to raise rent simply by changing tenants.
- Guaranteed legal representation for tenants facing above-guideline increase applications could help them take part in those Board proceedings.
Case against#
- The bill requires a registry and legal representation but gives no cost or staffing estimates.
- The registry would publish unit addresses and rents. The bill does not explain how privacy concerns would be handled.
- The Board could impose daily fines and rent reductions, but the bill does not set out detailed procedures or decision standards for using these powers.
- The bill’s rent limits depend on the unit’s rental history; the bill does not explain how missing or disputed history would be resolved.