Summary#
Bill 4, Stay Home If You Are Sick Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000. Its stated goal is to provide paid leave for specified personal and family emergencies and temporary financial support to employers facing higher costs.
- Employees would be entitled to up to 10 paid days per calendar year for listed personal or family reasons, subject to conditions.
- The first 14 days of certain emergency-related leaves under section 50.1 would be paid, in addition to the 10 days under section 50.
- Employers could require reasonable evidence of eligibility, but could not require a certificate from a qualified health practitioner.
- The Minister would have to set up a temporary employer-support program. The Minister could provide funding only if the Legislature appropriates money for it.
What it means for you#
- Employees: The 10 paid days could be used for your own illness, injury or medical emergency; a listed family member’s death, illness, injury or medical emergency; or an urgent matter concerning a listed family member. The list includes spouses, several relatives, and someone who considers you like family if any prescribed conditions are met.
- Employees: You would have to tell your employer you are taking leave, or, if that is not possible beforehand, tell them as soon as possible after it starts. An employer could ask for reasonable evidence, but not a health-practitioner certificate.
- Employees: If you have worked for your employer for less than a week, you would not yet qualify for paid days. Once you reach a week, any unpaid days of this leave already taken in that calendar year would count against the 10-day limit. An employer could count part of a day as a full day.
- Employees: The 10 paid days must be used before unpaid days available under your employment terms. Pay would generally be wages you would have earned, with special rules for performance-based pay, overtime, shift premiums and public holidays.
- Employees: The separate 14 paid days would apply to the emergency-related leaves covered by section 50.1. The bill leaves that section’s other rules in place; the supplied material does not provide enough detail to explain which situations qualify.
- Employers and taxpayers: The Minister would have to establish the support program, but payments to employers would be optional and depend on an appropriation. The bill does not directly change taxes or create a public application or approval process for employees.
Money#
No cost estimate or appropriation amount is provided in the supplied material.
- Employers would owe pay for qualifying leave under the bill.
- The Minister would have to implement an employer-support program, but could make payments only if the Legislature appropriates money. The bill sets no amount or formula for support.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current Employment Standards Act, 2000, so the bill’s changes cannot be fully checked against current law. Its explanatory note says the existing law has separate sick, family responsibility and bereavement leaves, and describes certain emergency leaves as unpaid.
- The bill does not define “urgent matter” or set out conditions for when someone may be treated as like a family member. Some details may be prescribed later.
- It does not set out how employers would apply for support, how funding would be calculated, or how the program would be overseen.
- The bill would take effect on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say whether it has received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that paid leave can let employees stay away from work for specified health or family emergencies without losing the day’s wages.
- The bill bars employers from requiring a health-practitioner certificate, while still allowing reasonable evidence. That could reduce the need for a medical certificate to prove eligibility.
- The separate 14 paid days for certain emergency-related leave would be on top of the 10 section 50 days.
- Temporary employer support could help employers adapt to increased leave costs, if the Legislature provides funding.
Case against#
- Employers would have to pay for leave, while the support program has no guaranteed funding or set payment amount.
- The bill leaves key terms and some family-member conditions to be prescribed or otherwise unspecified, making the exact reach of the entitlement unclear from the bill text.
- The bill does not set out how disputes over evidence, eligibility or employer-support payments would be handled.
- Counting a partial day as a full day could use up an employee’s entitlement faster than the time away from work.