Gender-affirming care advisory panel created

Summary#

Bill 42 would create a new Ontario law, not amend an existing Act. The bill text gives it the short title Gender Affirming Health Care Advisory Committee Act, 2022; the supplied bill title labels it 2024. Its stated goal is to improve access to and coverage for gender-affirming health care.

  • The Minister of Health must establish an advisory committee within 60 days after the Act starts. The Minister appoints its members.
  • The committee must include people from transgender, two-spirit, non-binary, intersex and gender-diverse communities, experienced health care providers, and other members the Minister considers useful. The Minister must make reasonable efforts for those communities to form a majority and for the committee to reflect the listed kinds of diversity.
  • The committee must study access, coverage, wait times, referral requirements and other listed issues, and recommend ways to improve care. It must consult specified health care groups and organizations, as well as any others it considers appropriate.
  • The committee must report within six months after it is established. Within 90 days after that, the Minister must tell the Assembly which recommendations the Minister recommends the Government implement. The bill does not require the Government to implement them.

What it means for you#

  • Trans, two-spirit, non-binary, intersex and gender-diverse people: The bill requires the committee to include members of these communities and to make reasonable efforts to reflect the listed groups, including youth, seniors, Indigenous people, racialized people and people in rural or remote areas. It does not change anyone’s eligibility for care or insurance coverage.
  • Health care providers and named organizations: Providers with relevant experience must be included, and the committee must consult specified providers and organizations. The bill does not require providers to change how they offer care.
  • Patients and the public: The committee must examine ways to improve access and coverage, including informed consent, referrals and wait times. These are matters for recommendations; the bill itself does not add covered treatments or create a new care service.
  • Minister and government: The Minister must establish the committee and report the Minister’s recommended measures to the Assembly. The committee advises; it does not decide coverage or require the Government to act on its recommendations.

Money#

The bill allows remuneration and expense payments for appointees, but gives no cost estimate.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set remuneration and expenses only if the Legislature appropriates money for that purpose.
  • The bill requires the Minister to establish a committee, but does not state its staffing, operating budget or other costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how members are selected, how the committee makes decisions, or how it will handle disagreement.
  • “Reasonable efforts” is not defined, and the bill does not set a minimum number of members from any listed group.
  • The bill does not specify how the committee’s recommendations would be assessed, funded or put into effect.
  • The bill does not set out a process for people to apply for care or coverage, or change existing coverage rules.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s status or whether it has received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A committee could bring patients’ experiences and providers’ knowledge together to examine barriers to care.
  • The required inquiry covers a range of issues, including wait times, coverage, referral requirements and different needs across Ontario.
  • Requiring efforts to include a diverse membership could help the committee consider experiences that might otherwise be missed.
  • A report and a ministerial response to the Assembly would put recommendations and the Minister’s position on the public record.

Case against#

  • The bill creates an advisory process, not a guarantee of better access, shorter waits or expanded coverage. The Government is not required to implement the recommendations.
  • It sets tight reporting deadlines but does not provide a budget, staff plan or detailed rules for how the committee will work.
  • The bill does not explain how the Minister will choose appointees or how the committee will show that it has reflected the diversity listed in the bill.
  • Its definition of gender-affirming health care is broad, and the bill does not set rules for deciding which services would ultimately be covered.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2024030401

    Defeated96 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 42

    AGAINST · 65FOR · 31

    65Against

    • PC63
    • Independent2

    31For

    • NDP21
    • Liberal8
    • Green2