Gender-affirming care advisory committee bill

Summary#

Bill 17, the Gender Affirming Health Care Advisory Committee Act, 2021, would create a new Act; it does not amend the Health Insurance Act. Its stated goal is to improve access to and coverage for gender-affirming health care by having a committee advise the Minister of Health.

  • The Minister must establish the committee within 60 days after the Act comes into force and appoint its members.
  • The committee must include people from named communities and health care providers with relevant experience. The Minister must make all reasonable efforts for most members to come from those communities and for the committee to reflect their diversity.
  • The committee must consult named health care organizations and professional groups, and others it considers appropriate. It must report recommendations to the Minister within six months of being established.
  • Within 90 days of receiving the report, the Minister must tell the Legislative Assembly which recommendations the Minister recommends the government implement. The bill does not require the government to implement them.
  • The committee must consider access, coverage, wait times, informed consent, referral requirements and other listed topics, including coverage for facial feminization surgery, chest contouring and electrolysis.

What it means for you#

  • Trans, two-spirit, non-binary, intersex and gender-diverse people: The bill would create an advisory process, not a new right to coverage or care. It would not itself change which services are covered or reduce wait times.
  • Committee members and health care organizations: The Minister would appoint committee members. The committee would have to consult specified groups, including primary care providers, Rainbow Health Ontario, and named transgender health organizations.
  • Health care providers and the public: The committee’s recommendations could inform later government decisions. This bill does not require patients to apply to the committee or providers to change how they deliver care.
  • People appointed to the committee: The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set their pay and expenses, but only if the Legislature has appropriated money for that purpose.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires the Minister to establish a committee, but does not set a budget or specify staffing.
  • Pay and expenses may be set for committee members only if the Legislature appropriates money for them. The amount is not stated.
  • The bill does not itself provide funding for health care or change insurance coverage.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how members will be selected, how often the committee will meet, or how it will make recommendations.
  • The bill does not require the government to adopt the committee’s recommendations. It also does not set a deadline for the government to act on them.
  • It does not say whether the committee’s report must be made public.
  • The bill defines gender-affirming health care broadly, but does not define terms such as “reasonable efforts” or “equitable access.”
  • No publicly available information on the expected cost or the amount, if any, appropriated for committee pay and expenses.

Case for#

  • A committee with members from the affected communities and experienced providers could bring different needs and practical knowledge into recommendations on access and coverage.
  • The bill lists issues for the committee to examine, including wait times, referral requirements, informed consent and services that it says are not currently covered under the Health Insurance Act.
  • Requiring consultation with named health care groups could help the committee gather input before making recommendations.

Case against#

  • The committee can recommend changes, but the bill does not require the government to make them. Access, coverage and wait times therefore would not change just because this bill passed.
  • The bill sets deadlines for creating the committee and delivering recommendations, but does not specify how the recommendations must be assessed or acted on.
  • The bill does not set a budget or explain how the committee’s work would be staffed. Pay and expenses depend on a separate appropriation.