Bill creates childcare workforce advisory committee

Summary#

Bill 191, the Childcare and Early Years Workforce Strategy Advisory Committee Act, 2024, would create a new Ontario law and establish an advisory committee. Its stated goal is to develop recommendations to support registered early childcare educators and the childcare and early years workforce, including addressing staffing shortages.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint committee members from listed groups, including educators and other workforce members, their organizations and unions, experts, Black, Indigenous and other communities of colour, Northern and rural communities, and Francophone communities.
  • The committee would make recommendations on wages, work standards, paid sick leave, paid planning and professional-development time, qualifications, recruitment, immigration, collective bargaining, and implementing the Canada-Wide Early Learning and Child Care system in Ontario.
  • The committee would have to publish an annual report and send it to the Ministers of Education, Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development, and Colleges and Universities.
  • After the first annual report, the Minister of Education would have to meet with the committee twice a year. Within six months of receiving each annual report, the Minister would have to publish a status report on government actions taken in response to its recommendations.
  • The Act would start on Royal Assent. The bill does not itself set wages or work standards, or require the government to adopt the committee’s recommendations.

What it means for you#

  • Early childhood educators and the childcare and early years workforce: The committee would consider recommendations on the listed workforce issues. The bill would not directly change your pay, benefits, leave, work standards, qualifications or bargaining rights.
  • Workforce organizations, unions and other named groups: Members would be appointed from these groups, but the bill does not guarantee a particular number of seats or a seat for every group.
  • Government ministers: The Minister of Education would have duties to meet with the committee and publish status reports. The other named ministers would receive the annual report; the bill does not give them similar meeting or reporting duties.
  • Public: The committee’s recommendations and the Minister of Education’s status reports would be published online.

Money#

No cost information is provided in the available material. No publicly available information.

  • The bill does not specify committee funding, staff, member pay, or an operating budget.
  • Meetings and public reports may require resources, but the bill gives no cost estimate or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set the committee’s size, how members are selected within the named groups, or how long they serve.
  • It does not set a deadline for the first annual report or explain how the committee would gather input.
  • It does not require the government to accept or implement recommendations. The status report must describe actions taken, but the bill does not require reasons or plans for recommendations not acted on.
  • The bill does not define key terms such as “childcare and early years workforce” or set rules for how the committee’s recommendations would relate to existing programs.

Case for#

  • A committee with members appointed from workforce groups, unions, experts and named communities could bring different perspectives to recommendations on staffing shortages.
  • The list of subjects gives the committee a broad remit, from pay and work standards to recruitment, qualifications and collective bargaining.
  • Annual public reports could make the recommendations visible, while the Minister of Education’s status reports could show what actions the government has taken.

Case against#

  • The bill creates an advisory body, not a requirement to change wages, benefits, staffing or other conditions. Recommendations could be made without being implemented.
  • The bill does not specify the committee’s size, how representation would be balanced, or how it would hear from people outside its membership.
  • The bill does not state how much the committee would cost or how it would be funded. It also gives no deadline for the first report.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2024052901

    Defeated104 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 191

    AGAINST · 67FOR · 37

    67Against

    • PC67

    37For

    • NDP25
    • Liberal8
    • Green2
    • Independent2