Summary#
Bill 43, the Making Northern Ontario Highways Safer Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act. Its stated goal is to make northern Ontario highways safer by requiring the Minister to ensure snow is removed to set standards on highways under the Ministry’s jurisdiction.
- The Minister would have to ensure highways meet one of five snow-removal standards after a snowfall. The bill does not say the Minister must do the work directly.
- A regulation would have to classify all highways under the Ministry’s jurisdiction, using traffic quality and quantity and any other criteria set by regulation.
- All 400-series highways, the QEW, and Highways 11 and 17 would be Class 1, including two-lane portions of Highways 11 and 17.
- Class 1 highways would have to be bare of snow within eight hours after a snowfall ends; Class 2 within 16 hours; and Class 3 within 24 hours.
- Class 4 highways would need a bare strip 2.5 metres wide in the centre within 24 hours. Class 5 highways would need to be plowed to a snow-packed driving surface within 24 hours, with sand applied to improve friction.
- The bill would take effect on a date set by proclamation. The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so current legal standards could not be checked against it.
What it means for you#
- Drivers: If the bill became law and took effect, the stated snow-removal deadlines would apply to highways under the Ministry’s jurisdiction. The bill does not directly change driver duties, or promise that every road will be bare of snow.
- People travelling on Highways 11 and 17: These highways would be Class 1 even where they have only two lanes. The bill sets the same eight-hour bare-pavement standard for them as for other Class 1 highways.
- The Minister and Ministry: The Minister would have a duty to ensure the standards are met and to make a regulation classifying the Ministry’s highways. The bill does not set out a process for checking or enforcing compliance.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.
- The bill gives the Minister responsibility for ensuring the standards are met and requires a regulation classifying highways, but does not specify funding, staffing, or how much implementation would cost.
- Any effect on highway maintenance spending is unknown.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not show what winter-maintenance rules already apply under the current Act or through other arrangements.
- The bill does not define terms such as “snowfall,” “bare of snow,” or “snow-packed driving surface.”
- It does not explain how the Minister would classify highways in practice, or what other classification criteria could be set by regulation.
- The bill gives no weather-related exceptions, measurement rules, reporting duties, or process for complaints or enforcement.
- The start date depends on a proclamation, and no date is given in the supplied material.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it would set clear, legally required snow-removal deadlines instead of leaving the standards to vary by road.
- The five classes would set different standards for different types of highways, while still requiring a defined level of service on lower-class roads.
- Naming Highways 11 and 17 as Class 1 would give their two-lane portions the same eight-hour standard as other Class 1 highways.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill sets firm deadlines but does not explain how they would apply during severe or continuing snowfall.
- The bill does not say how compliance would be measured or what happens if a standard is missed.
- The required standards may affect maintenance costs, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan.
- The classification process depends partly on criteria that could be set later by regulation, so the final class of many highways is not clear from the bill alone.