Snow-removal standards bill for highways

Summary#

Bill 125, the Making Northern Ontario Highways Safer Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act. Its stated goal is to make Northern Ontario highways safer by setting winter snow-removal standards; meeting those standards is not guaranteed to make roads safe.

  • The Minister of Transportation would have to ensure snow is removed from highways under the Ministry’s jurisdiction to meet standards set by highway class.
  • The Minister would have to make regulations classifying those highways, based on traffic quality and quantity and other criteria set by regulation.
  • The bill itself makes all 400-series highways, the QEW, and Highways 11 and 17 Class 1—including two-lane portions of Highways 11 and 17.
  • Class 1 highways would have to have all pavement bare of snow within eight hours after a snowfall ends. The deadline would be 16 hours for Class 2 and 24 hours for Class 3.
  • For Class 4, a 2.5-metre strip in the centre of the highway would have to be bare within 24 hours. Class 5 highways would have to be ploughed to a snow-packed driving surface within 24 hours, with sand applied to improve friction.

What it means for you#

  • People driving on highways under the Ministry’s jurisdiction: The bill would set snow-removal standards based on the highway’s class. The standards differ by class; they do not require every highway to be bare of snow.
  • The Minister of Transportation: The Minister would have a duty to ensure the standards are met and to classify Ministry-jurisdiction highways by regulation.
  • Municipalities: The bill applies to highways within the Ministry’s jurisdiction. It does not set standards for other roads.
  • People using roads generally: The bill does not specify fines, a way to enforce the standards, or a process for reporting or resolving complaints.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost is provided in the supplied material.

  • The bill would require the Minister to ensure snow is removed to the specified standards. It gives no estimate of the cost or the staff, equipment, or funding needed.
  • The bill does not set a tax, fee, or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define terms used in classification, including “major,” “intermediate,” “minor,” or what makes a highway qualify as Class 1 based on traffic quality or volume.
  • The Minister’s regulations would classify Ministry-jurisdiction highways, but the bill does not set a deadline or explain how the Minister must apply the criteria beyond those stated.
  • The bill does not describe how compliance would be measured, reported, or enforced, or what happens if a standard is missed.
  • The bill would start on a day set by proclamation. The supplied material does not say when that would be.
  • The current Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act was not supplied, so I could not verify how these standards compare with current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make winter driving safer by setting clear snow-removal deadlines.
  • A possible argument for the highway classes is that they allow different standards for roads with different traffic levels and roles.
  • Naming major routes as Class 1 would make their classification clear, including on two-lane portions of Highways 11 and 17.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how compliance would be checked or what action would follow if a deadline were missed.
  • Some classification terms are undefined, leaving important details to regulations made by the Minister.
  • The bill sets firm deadlines but gives no cost estimate or details about the resources needed to meet them.
  • The standards vary by class, so some roads would not have to be cleared to bare pavement.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2019110702

    Defeated97 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 125

    AGAINST · 59FOR · 38

    59Against

    • PC59

    38For

    • NDP34
    • Liberal2
    • Green1
    • Independent1