Summary#
Bill 62, the Farmland and Arable Land Strategy Act, 2023, would create a new Act; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to protect Ontario farmland and arable land, including by developing a strategy and setting up an advisory committee.
- The Minister of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs must develop a strategic action plan aimed at protecting farmland and arable land from development, aggregate mining, and the effects of fluctuating commodity prices and the availability of vacant land.
- The Minister must consult relevant groups, including the farming community, land use planners, municipal partners and the outdoors community. Within nine months after Royal Assent, the Minister must publish a report setting out the plan and provide it to the committee.
- The Act would establish an advisory committee of no more than 11 members. A selection committee made up of members of the Legislative Assembly would select them. The committee must represent the farming community, the real estate industry, the outdoors community and any other communities or industries the selection committee considers appropriate.
- The advisory committee must review land-use policies, legislation, municipal by-laws, farming best practices and tax policies related to Ontario’s farmland and arable land. It must provide findings and recommendations to the Minister at least every six months; the Minister must table each report in the Assembly as soon as reasonably possible.
What it means for you#
- Farmers, landowners, developers and municipalities: The bill would not itself ban development or aggregate mining, change land-use rules, or change tax policies. It requires a plan aimed at protection, but does not require specific protections to be adopted.
- Groups consulted: The Minister must consult the named groups when developing the strategy. The bill does not set out how consultation will work or require the Minister to accept participants’ recommendations.
- Committee members: They would have to review the listed policies and practices and report to the Minister at least every six months. The bill gives the committee an advisory role, not a power to change laws or land-use decisions.
- General public: If passed, the Act would start on Royal Assent. It does not create a direct service, benefit, fee or fine.
Money#
The bill requires ministerial and committee work, but no cost estimate is provided.
- The bill does not specify funding, staff numbers, member pay or other costs.
- No publicly available information.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not say what actions the strategic plan must recommend or require after it is published.
- “Farmland” is not defined. “Arable land” is defined as land that is or can be cultivated, including pasture land and cropland.
- The bill does not explain what protection from commodity-price changes or the availability of vacant land would involve.
- It does not set out how committee members are chosen beyond the selection committee’s membership, or how the required representation is assessed.
- The bill does not specify how the new committee’s work would relate to existing government programs or land-use processes.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that farmland is finite, and the bill’s preamble says Ontario is losing arable land. A province-wide strategy could bring land-use, farming and tax policies into one review.
- Required consultation could bring farming, planning, municipal and outdoors perspectives into the strategy.
- Regular committee reports and public tabling could keep farmland policy under review and make advice visible to the Assembly.
Case against#
- The bill requires a plan aimed at protection, but does not require any particular land protections or changes to land-use rules. The goal may therefore not lead to direct limits on development or mining.
- The committee can advise and recommend, but the bill does not require the Minister or government to act on its advice.
- The bill requires new work and reports but gives no cost, staffing or funding details.
- The scope of the plan’s aims, especially protection from commodity-price changes and vacant-land availability, is not explained.