Voter-choice primaries could reshape ballots

Summary#

SB 1592, “Relating to primary elections,” would have amended Oregon election laws and added new rules for certain offices. Its stated goal was to change how primary elections work and how some vacancies are filled. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • For “voter choice offices”—including U.S. Senate and House seats, several statewide offices, and state legislative seats—all candidates would appear on one primary ballot, regardless of party. The two candidates with the most votes would advance to the general election.
  • A political party could opt out of that primary and nominate candidates through its own process, but it would have to provide fair and open participation for its affiliated voters. It could not receive public funds for that process.
  • A voter could vote in a primary for a voter choice office unless the voter’s affiliated party opted out. The presidential primary would remain outside these new rules.
  • Parties could have up to three endorsements printed beside a candidate’s name. Candidates would have to accept the endorsement, and parties would need published rules for fair and open participation by interested affiliated voters.
  • The bill would change how vacancies in nominations are filled, including allowing the next-highest primary vote-getter to take a vacancy if that candidate received at least 1% of the votes cast for the office.
  • It would repeal statutory provisions about precinct committeepersons and county and state party central committees.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: In a voter choice office primary, you could vote regardless of party affiliation, unless your party opts out. The two highest vote-getters would advance, even if they are from the same party.
  • Voters affiliated with an opting-out party: You could not vote in that office’s primary under the bill. Your party’s own nomination process would need to allow fair and open participation by its affiliated voters.
  • Candidates: You would not have to be affiliated with a party to run for a voter choice office. The bill also allows party endorsements, not party nominations, to appear beside candidates’ names.
  • Political parties: A party opting out would have to give up public funds for its own nomination process. To endorse candidates, it would need to file rules with the Secretary of State and publish them at least 180 days before the relevant election.
  • General public: The bill would not change presidential primaries. It would not guarantee that a particular party’s candidate appears in the general election.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total cost.

  • The bill would require election officials to carry out new ballot and election duties, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate or staffing estimate.
  • A party choosing its own nomination process instead of the primary could not receive public funds for that process. The material does not say how much funding this could involve.

What is unclear#

  • “Fair and open participation” is not defined in the supplied bill text.
  • The bill does not set out detailed rules for how an opting-out party must run its nomination process, such as timelines, appeals or oversight.
  • Local governing bodies could designate additional offices as voter choice offices; the bill does not say which ones would do so.
  • The supplied material does not include the full bill text or the current versions of the laws it would amend. I could not verify which existing rules the bill would change and which it would carry forward.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that voters would choose between all candidates for covered offices in one primary, rather than being limited by party affiliation.
  • Advancing the two highest vote-getters could give general-election voters a choice between the candidates who received the most primary votes.
  • Allowing parties to opt out could let them use their own nomination process, while requiring fair and open participation by affiliated voters.

Case against#

  • The two candidates advancing could both be from the same party, leaving general-election voters without a candidate from another party among the top two.
  • Voters affiliated with a party that opts out would be excluded from that office’s primary, while unaffiliated voters could vote in a participating party’s primary.
  • The bill’s fair-and-open requirement lacks detail, making it unclear how compliance would be judged or challenged.
  • New election duties could cost public money, but the supplied material includes no estimate.