Top-two primary for selected offices

Summary#

SB 562, “Require top two primary for certain offices,” was a bill to amend existing Montana election laws, not create a separate law. It would have required the two candidates with the most votes in certain primaries to advance to the general election regardless of party affiliation; that was the bill’s main change, not a guaranteed result of the stated goal. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • The top-two rule would apply to races for U.S. senator and representative; governor and lieutenant governor; secretary of state; attorney general; state auditor; state superintendent of public instruction; public service commissioners; clerk of the supreme court; state senator; Montana House member; and county commissioner.
  • For those races, the top two vote-getters would advance, rather than candidates advancing based on party affiliation.
  • The bill would amend many election-law provisions, including candidate filing, ballot and election administration, and rules for filling some vacancies. The supplied text is incomplete, so the full set of changes cannot be assessed.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: If the bill had become law, the listed races would use a primary that selects the top two candidates by votes, regardless of party. The supplied material does not establish the exact ballot or voting process.
  • Candidates and political parties: A candidate’s party affiliation would not determine whether they advance; their vote total would. The bill would not guarantee that candidates from different parties reach the general election.
  • Election officials: They would have to administer the new top-two process for the listed offices. The bill failed, so officials do not have new duties under it.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The supplied material does not give an appropriation or estimate costs for election administration.
  • It is not enough to determine whether implementation would require additional staff or other spending.

What is unclear#

  • The bill text supplied here cuts off before the full set of amendments. Later provisions may contain rules that are not available for review.
  • The current Montana laws being amended were not supplied, so I could not verify which provisions would be new and which would restate or adjust existing rules.
  • The available text does not establish all details of how candidates qualify, how votes are counted in a tie, or how the top-two process would fit with other primary rules.
  • The bill proposed an immediate effective date, but it failed and therefore did not take effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that voters in the listed races would choose between candidates based on votes, without party affiliation deciding who advances.
  • The top-two rule could give voters a choice between two candidates in the general election even if both share a party affiliation.
  • Applying a common advancement rule to the listed offices could make the outcome of those primaries easier to understand: the two highest vote-getters advance.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is that both candidates advancing could belong to the same party, leaving no candidate from another party in the general election for that race.
  • The supplied text does not show enough detail to judge how candidate access, ballots, ties, or other election rules would work alongside the new process.
  • The bill would change many election-law provisions, but the available material does not show the full scope or cost of those changes.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1534974

    Passed9 members voted

    (S) State Administration--To Table

    FOR · 9

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    9For

    • Republican6
    • Democratic3

    0Against