Ranked-choice voting would replace primaries

Summary#

SB 1130, titled “Ranked-choice voting, granting rule-making authority, and making an appropriation,” would amend the Wisconsin Statutes; it would not create a standalone voting law. It would require ranked-choice voting for most elections for public office. Its stated goal is to put that voting method in place; the bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • Voters could rank candidates in order of preference, but would not have to rank every candidate. For a single seat, the lowest-ranked candidate is eliminated in rounds and votes move to the next available preference until a candidate wins.
  • For elections filling several seats, candidates would be elected by meeting a vote threshold; surplus votes and votes for eliminated candidates would be transferred under rules in the bill.
  • The bill would remove most primary elections. It keeps partisan primaries, special partisan primaries, and presidential preference primaries, and uses ranked-choice voting in those primaries.
  • The Wisconsin Elections Commission would have to prescribe a tally-sheet form for ranked-choice counts. It could spend money on implementation and make grants to counties and municipalities for equipment, software, and secure technology.
  • The bill’s analysis says recall elections would be excluded. Towns and villages could not use ranked-choice voting to nominate candidates at a caucus.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: You could rank candidates for an office or seat. You could leave rankings blank or rank only some candidates. If your ranked choices are eliminated, or you do not rank enough candidates, your ballot may be “exhausted” and stop counting in later rounds.
  • Candidates and political parties: Most primary elections would be replaced by ranked-choice voting at the general election. The retained partisan primaries would also use ranked-choice voting to choose who advances.
  • Counties and municipalities: They would take part in ranked-choice voting and could apply for commission grants for equipment, software, and secure technology. The bill does not set out an application process or say how much grant money would be available.
  • Election officials: They would use the commission’s tally-sheet form and conduct the required rounds of counting. The bill also sets out how to handle ties and certain ballot markings.
  • General public: The bill concerns elections for offices and seats, not referendum questions. It does not change who is eligible to vote.

Money#

The bill authorizes implementation spending and creates appropriation entries, but the available material gives no dollar amount. No publicly available information.

  • The Elections Commission could spend money on administration, equipment, software, and secure technologies, and make grants to counties and municipalities for those purposes.
  • The bill text provided does not include the appropriation amounts or the fiscal estimate it says will be printed with the bill.

What is unclear#

  • The current Wisconsin statutes being amended were not supplied, so I could not verify which procedures already exist and which would be new.
  • The provided text does not include all bill sections, including the details of the appropriations and some referenced exceptions.
  • The bill does not explain how voters would be taught to use ranked-choice ballots, or how election offices would manage the practical change.
  • The bill sets counting rules but does not explain in the provided material how those rules would interact with existing recount or election-challenge procedures.
  • It is unclear how much funding counties and municipalities could receive, and how implementation costs would be divided.

Case for#

  • The method lets voters express backup choices, which can help determine a winner without treating every vote as only a choice between the top two candidates.
  • For a single-seat contest, the bill seeks a winner with a majority of continuing preferences after lower-ranked candidates are eliminated.
  • A standard statewide counting method and tally-sheet form could make ranked-choice counts more consistent across jurisdictions.
  • Replacing most primaries with ranked-choice voting at the election could reduce the need for separate primary contests. The bill does not estimate whether that would save money.

Case against#

  • Counting is more complex than counting first-choice votes alone, especially in multi-seat contests, where the bill uses thresholds and transfers surplus votes.
  • Voters may rank too few candidates for their ballot to count in later rounds. The bill does not require rankings or make an exhausted ballot count further.
  • The bill does not provide a cost estimate in the supplied material, even though it authorizes implementation spending and grants.
  • The bill changes many election and nomination procedures, but the available materials do not show a complete comparison with current law or all the details needed to assess the transition.