Banks could switch to receipts-only apportionment

Summary#

H-8611 amends Rhode Island’s existing law on taxation of banks, in Chapter 44-14, “Taxation of Banks.” The supplied bill status says it is signed into law; it applies to tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2025. Its stated goal is to change how banks’ income is apportioned and allocated for state tax purposes.

  • Without an election, a bank doing business both inside and outside Rhode Island generally apportions income using the average of its receipts, property and payroll factors.
  • A bank may elect to apportion income using only its receipts factor. The election starts with the tax year chosen and generally continues in later years.
  • After at least five tax years following the election year, a bank may ask to revoke the election if facts or law have materially changed. The tax administrator may request additional information under oath.
  • A bank using the receipts-only election cannot claim benefits under Chapter 64.5 of Title 42.
  • If the receipts factor is missing because both its numerator and denominator are zero, the bank’s whole net income is taxable under the cited bank-tax provisions. A zero numerator alone does not make the factor missing.
  • If the usual apportionment rules are not reasonably adapted to approximate a bank’s Rhode Island income, the bank may apply for an alternative method, or the tax administrator may require one.

What it means for you#

  • Banks doing business inside and outside Rhode Island: If you do not elect receipts-only apportionment, the three-factor formula generally applies, subject to the alternative-method rules. The bill does not say how the receipts factor is calculated; that is in a separate provision not supplied here.
  • Banks choosing receipts-only apportionment: You must make the election on a form prescribed by the tax administrator and file it with your tax return. The election generally continues in later years, and you give up any benefits under Chapter 64.5 of Title 42 while using it.
  • Banks seeking a different method: You must attach to your filed return a statement explaining why the standard rules are not reasonably adapted to approximate your Rhode Island income and describing the method you seek. The tax administrator may require additional information. If the administrator finds the usual rules are not reasonably adapted, the administrator must determine the income using reasonable methods.
  • People and businesses other than affected banks: The bill does not directly change your tax rules or create a new tax rate.

The supplied text does not include the existing version of the law, so it is not possible to verify which parts of the described rules are new and which were already in force.

Money#

No publicly available information on expected revenue or administrative costs.

  • A bank’s tax liability could differ depending on its apportionment method and business figures; the materials do not estimate the effect.
  • The receipts-only election bars a bank from claiming benefits under Chapter 64.5 of Title 42. The materials do not describe or value those benefits.

What is unclear#

  • The existing law is not supplied, so the exact change from current law cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not define what counts as a “material change” that could support revoking a receipts-only election.
  • It does not set detailed criteria or timelines for deciding alternative-method requests.
  • The calculation of the receipts factor is in a separate section not supplied here.
  • No publicly available information on the number of banks likely to elect the receipts-only method or the effect on state revenue.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a receipts-only option gives banks a simpler alternative to combining receipts, property and payroll in one formula.
  • Allowing an alternative method when the usual rules do not reasonably approximate Rhode Island income could help address cases where the standard formula gives an unsuitable result.
  • The rule that a receipts-only election continues over time may make banks’ tax treatment more consistent from year to year.

Case against#

  • A receipts-only formula may not approximate Rhode Island income well for every bank; the bill does not explain when receipts alone are a good measure.
  • The election is difficult to undo: a bank generally must wait at least five later tax years and show a material change in facts or law.
  • Banks using the election lose benefits under Chapter 64.5, but the supplied material does not explain which benefits or their value.
  • The alternative-method rules give the tax administrator a role in requiring a different method, but the bill does not spell out detailed decision criteria or timelines.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1708449

    Passed71 members voted

    Passage

    FOR · 71

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    71For

    • Democratic60
    • Republican10
    • Independent1

    0Against

    4 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1714896

    Passed10 members voted

    House Committee on Finance: Passage

    FOR · 10

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    10For

    • Democratic9
    • Republican1

    0Against

    5 members were paired and sat out the vote.