Insurers would pay appraisers directly

Summary#

S-3560, “An Act Relating to Insurance—Motor Vehicle Appraisal Provision,” would amend Rhode Island’s existing Motor Vehicle Appraisal Provision in the General Laws. Its stated goal is to require insurers to pay an insured’s or claimant’s chosen appraiser, and an umpire appraiser when applicable, directly when given a signed direction to pay. The bill is introduced and is not law; it would take effect upon passage.

  • An insurer must not refuse to honor a direction to pay signed by an insured or claimant for direct payment to the insured’s chosen appraiser and, if applicable, the umpire.
  • The payment direction applies within the motor-vehicle appraisal process described in the amended section. The bill does not set a fee or explain how the direction must be submitted.
  • The bill text also contains rules about selecting appraisers, resolving disagreements and allocating some appraisal costs. The available material does not establish which of those rules are new; the explanatory note identifies direct payment as the change.

What it means for you#

  • Insured people and claimants: If you use the appraisal process and sign a direction to pay, the insurer must not refuse to pay your chosen appraiser directly. The bill does not say that you must use an appraiser or create an application process.
  • Insurance companies: You would have to honor such a direction. The bill does not specify when payment is due or how to handle a disputed amount.
  • Appraisers and umpires: The bill identifies you as possible direct recipients of insurer payment when a direction covers your work. It does not set your fees or payment terms.
  • People with motor-vehicle claims generally: The proposal changes the payment route for appraisal services. It does not directly change insurance coverage, the amount of a vehicle loss, or the right to use the appraisal process.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • Insurers would have to pay appraisers directly when given a qualifying direction to pay. The bill does not say whether this changes the total amount an insurer must pay.
  • The text includes cost-allocation rules for appraisals, but it is unclear how direct payment would work alongside them.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define the required form or contents of a “direction to pay,” or set a deadline for payment.
  • It does not explain what happens if the insurer disputes an appraiser’s fee or the direction’s validity.
  • The bill does not explain how direct payment interacts with the appraisal-cost rules in the section.
  • The current version of the amended law was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which appraisal rules already apply and which wording this bill would change.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that direct payment could spare an insured or claimant from having to pay an appraiser first and seek reimbursement later.
  • Requiring insurers not to refuse a signed direction could make the payment route clearer for people using the appraisal process.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set payment deadlines or explain how disputes over fees or directions would be handled.
  • It is unclear how the new direct-payment rule fits with the section’s cost-allocation rules, including when the insurer reimburses appraisal costs or the parties split an umpire’s cost.
  • Without the current law, readers cannot tell how much of the appraisal process in the bill is existing law and how much would change.