Summary#
The passed bill is the Moveable Transactions (Scotland) Act 2023. It creates rules for transferring claims, sets up two public registers managed by the Keeper of the Registers of Scotland, creates a way to secure debts against certain moveable property without handing it over, and ends the creation of agricultural charges. Its stated goal is to change Scots law on these transactions; the text does not guarantee any particular economic result.
- A claim can be transferred by a signed or authenticated document and then by notice to the debtor or registration. The rules cover future claims, claims assigned in parts, and claims assigned subject to a condition. An individual cannot assign a claim for their wages or salary.
- The Keeper must manage a Register of Assignations and a Register of Statutory Pledges. The Act sets rules for entries, searches, corrections and information requests.
- A statutory pledge can secure a debt against certain moveable property without the creditor taking possession. It requires a document identifying the property and debt, and registration.
- An individual can grant a statutory pledge only in specified business, charity or unincorporated-association circumstances. The property must be a permitted asset; corporeal property (physical property) must be worth more than £3,000 when the document is granted.
- A secured creditor may, after required notice and subject to court-order rules, take steps to possess, sell, let, protect or manage pledged property, license intellectual property, or appropriate property (take it in satisfaction of the debt).
- The Act repeals the Transmission of Moveable Property (Scotland) Act 1862 and ends the creation of agricultural charges. Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers; the supplied material gives no start dates.
What it means for you#
- Debtors: If a claim is transferred, you may still use against the new holder defences you could have used against the previous holder, subject to the Act’s rules. You may ask for evidence or information about an assignation and, in specified cases, withhold performance until you receive it. Payment in good faith to the person you last knew held the claim discharges the debt to the extent paid.
- Workers: The Act says an individual cannot assign a claim for wages or salary, including listed employment payments such as bonuses, holiday pay and redundancy payments.
- Businesses and lenders: Businesses can use statutory pledges over eligible property, including certain property they acquire later. Lenders can register pledges and, after a pledge becomes enforceable, use the enforcement powers set out in the Act. They must follow notice, sale-price and proceeds rules.
- People buying property: In specified cases, a good-faith buyer can acquire pledged property free of the pledge, including certain ordinary-course business sales and purchases for personal, domestic or household use. Separate rules apply to motor vehicles.
- People whose home is involved: A court order is generally required to enforce a statutory pledge over a person’s sole or main residence, unless the specified people agree in writing to enforcement without an order after the pledge becomes enforceable. The court must consider whether enforcement is reasonable.
- General public: The Act creates register and enforcement machinery, not a new front-line service or a general benefit. Most provisions do not start automatically on passage; ministers must set commencement dates.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Act allows fees for registrations, searches, extracts and some corrections, but the supplied text gives no fee amounts.
- The Keeper must manage both registers. The text gives no staffing plan or cost estimate.
- Some searches are free when a not-for-profit money adviser searches on behalf of an individual.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not give the commencement dates or the detailed rules and fees that ministers may set for the registers.
- It does not say how many staff or how much funding the Keeper will need to run the registers.
- The text leaves some details to later rules, including how some people and property must be identified in the registers.
- The supplied material does not include the full current versions of the Acts being amended, so it is not possible here to verify every change against current law.
- The Act requires ministers to review its operation after a five-year review period, including how statutory pledges work for sole traders and small businesses. The supplied text does not contain that review.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that registration gives lenders and others a public record of certain claim transfers and pledges.
- The statutory pledge could let some businesses use eligible property as security without handing it over to the lender.
- The Act sets out protections for debtors and buyers, as well as rules on notice, enforcement and how money from enforcement is applied.
- The Act allows claims to be assigned in ways that include future claims and identifiable groups of claims, which may make some transfers easier to document.
Case against#
- One concern is that the rules are detailed and rely on registers and later regulations; the supplied material gives no cost estimate for running the system.
- A statutory pledge can give a creditor wide enforcement powers, including selling property, while the Act’s protections vary by property and situation.
- The special limits on individuals mean not every person or asset can use a statutory pledge; the supplied material does not explain how often it will be available to sole traders or small businesses.
- Register mistakes can affect whether a pledge or assignation is effective and can affect third parties. The Act provides correction and compensation rules, but those processes may still be difficult to navigate.