Geoengineering ban would be felony

Summary#

HB-1294, “An Act to prohibit geoengineering in this state,” would add a new section to South Dakota’s Chapter 34A-1. It would prohibit anyone from engaging in defined geoengineering in the state and make a violation a Class 6 felony; the stated goal is to prohibit geoengineering. The bill is not law. The supplied status says the Agriculture and Natural Resources committee deferred it to the 41st legislative day.

  • The ban would cover intentional, large-scale intervention in Earth’s climate system to counteract climate change by removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere or reflecting sunlight away from Earth.
  • The prohibition would apply to “no person”; the bill does not name exceptions or limit the ban to particular industries or activities.
  • A violation would be a Class 6 felony. The supplied material does not state the penalty range or name an enforcement agency.

What it means for you#

  • People, businesses, and research institutions: If you engage in activity that meets the bill’s definition of geoengineering in South Dakota, the bill would prohibit it. A violation would be a Class 6 felony.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or everyday activities that do not meet its definition of geoengineering.
  • Current law: The existing text of Chapter 34A-1 was not supplied, so I could not verify whether any related rules already apply.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill provides no funding or fee.
  • It creates a felony offense, but no information is provided about enforcement staffing or costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “large-scale,” “intervention,” or what it means to “engage in” geoengineering.
  • It does not explain how activity would be treated if it is partly inside and partly outside South Dakota.
  • It names no enforcement agency and sets out no investigation, charging, or review process.
  • The supplied material does not state the penalty range for a Class 6 felony or identify exceptions or defences.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent intentional, large-scale climate interventions of the two listed kinds within South Dakota.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that a clear prohibition could prevent those activities without creating a permit or approval process.
  • Limiting the definition to interventions intended to counteract climate change gives the ban a stated purpose and two specified methods.

Case against#

  • One concern is that key terms, including “large-scale” and “engage in,” are undefined, making the ban’s reach unclear.
  • The bill makes violations felonies but the supplied text gives no exception or defence.
  • It is unclear who would enforce the ban or how decisions about whether conduct meets the definition would be made.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1631414

    Passed10 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 7AGAINST · 3

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican7

    3Against

    • Republican3

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.