Ban natural asset companies from operating

Summary#

HB 1318, “Prohibit natural asset companies,” would create a new chapter in Title 5; it does not amend an existing Act in the supplied text. Its stated goal is to prohibit natural asset companies from operating or acquiring interests in South Dakota and to bar state support for them. The supplied status says the bill was deferred to the 41st legislative day; it is not shown as enacted.

  • The bill defines a “natural asset” as arable soil, air quality, biodiversity, drainage management, extractive resources, natural disaster resilience, pollution sinks, or water quality. A “natural asset company” must meet several tests, including being listed by the SEC as one, and excludes nonprofits, privately held farms, and companies providing physical ecosystem-management services under government contracts.
  • The state could not do business with such a company in a way that gives it an interest or right in public land or state resources. State money could not be invested in the company or related funds or investments, and the state could not engage with certain bond offerings involving it. People overseeing prohibited investments or bonding would have to arrange for the prohibited investment or use of money to end immediately.
  • A natural asset company could not operate or acquire assets or interests in South Dakota. Natural assets could not be used for its benefit or transferred or promised to it. If it acquired an ownership interest, ownership would have to revert to the prior owner, and related easements, liens, or other listed interests would be void.
  • The Secretary of State would have to revoke a company’s authority to do business if it became a natural asset company, and could not accept filings or grant authority to one.
  • State agencies, political subdivisions, and private citizens adversely affected by a violation could sue. A court could award the plaintiff attorney fees and costs.
  • The chapter would not apply to the South Dakota Retirement System, the State Investment Council, or assets managed by the Council.

What it means for you#

  • State agencies and officials: They would face restrictions on business dealings, investments, and bond-related activity involving natural asset companies. The chapter also requires action to dispose of prohibited investments or uses of state money.
  • Companies: An entity meeting the bill’s definition could not operate or acquire the listed interests in the state. Its business authority could be revoked. A contract entered into on or after July 1, 2026, in violation of the chapter would be void and unenforceable.
  • Landowners and other rights holders: If a natural asset company acquired an ownership interest in a natural asset, the bill says ownership must revert to the prior owner. The text does not say whether that rule applies to interests acquired before the chapter takes effect.
  • People affected by a violation: State agencies, local governments, and private citizens could bring a court action if adversely affected.
  • General public: The bill does not directly create a new public service, benefit, tax, or fine.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require specified state investment and bond-related activities to stop, but gives no estimate of the financial effect.
  • It provides no appropriation or staffing estimate. No publicly available information.
  • A court could award attorney fees and costs to a plaintiff who brings a successful action; the amount is not specified.

What is unclear#

  • “Measurable ecological outcome” and other key terms are not defined in the bill. It is unclear how the SEC-listing test would be applied.
  • The bill does not set out how violations would be identified or how the required disposition of prohibited investments would work.
  • The text does not specify when the chapter would take effect, apart from setting July 1, 2026, for the contract rule.
  • It is unclear how the ownership-reversion rule would apply to interests acquired before the chapter takes effect.
  • The materials do not include current South Dakota statutes on these topics, so I could not verify how the new chapter would interact with existing law. The retirement-system and State Investment Council exception may also affect the investment restrictions, but the bill gives no examples.
  • No publicly available information on implementation costs or the bill’s expected financial effects.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent private entities from gaining rights in natural assets or public resources through a company structure focused on ecological outcomes.
  • A possible argument for prohibiting state investments and bond support is that public money should not support companies the bill bars from operating in the state.
  • The bill includes a way for affected public bodies and private citizens to ask a court to address violations.

Case against#

  • The ban reaches not only state dealings but also company operations and acquisitions, and it provides for ownership to revert if a company acquires an interest. The bill does not explain how existing interests would be handled.
  • The definition depends partly on SEC listing and uses terms the bill does not define, which may make it hard to know which entities are covered.
  • The Secretary of State’s revocation duties and the requirement to dispose of prohibited investments may have costs or practical effects, but the bill supplies no estimates or process details.
  • The exception for the retirement system, the State Investment Council, and Council-managed assets means the restrictions would not apply to those named entities or assets.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1637055

    Passed13 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 7AGAINST · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican6
    • Democratic1

    6Against

    • Republican6