Local mining rules could shape state permits

Summary#

HB 1288, “Modify the authority of a political subdivision to adopt mining ordinances,” would amend South Dakota’s mining laws and add a new provision for sand, gravel and aggregate mining. Its stated goal is to let some counties and municipalities set local mining requirements that do not conflict with state law or rules. The supplied status says the bill was deferred; it is not law.

  • A county or first- or second-class municipality with a comprehensive plan could adopt ordinances or requirements for sand, gravel and aggregate mining.
  • The state Board of Minerals and Environment generally could not issue a mining permit until the applicant had met local requirements and obtained required local permits.
  • If an applicant substantially followed the local permit process but faced administrative delay, the Board could issue a conditional permit. The applicant would have to obtain the local permits within 60 days, and could not start mining until notifying the Board in writing that the permits were obtained.
  • The Board could consider local proceedings and actions when deciding whether to issue or deny a permit.
  • The bill ties compliance with the new local requirements to the state mining-license requirements for each site. The text also sets a $100 annual fee for each mine site, but the supplied materials do not show whether that fee would change.
  • The bill also amends existing authority for local mining ordinances. The supplied copy does not preserve its underlining and strikeouts, and the current statutes were not provided, so the exact change to that existing authority cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • Counties and municipalities: Qualifying local governments could adopt mining requirements for sand, gravel and aggregate operations. The new provision does not let them conflict with state laws or rules. It bars additional bonds or sureties where state law or a rule already requires them.
  • Mining operators: For a covered operation, applicants would generally need local permits before the state Board could issue a permit. A conditional state permit could be issued during administrative delay, but it would not allow mining to begin before local permits were obtained and the Board was notified in writing.
  • The Board of Minerals and Environment: It would have to account for local permits and compliance, and could consider local proceedings and actions. It could use the administrative-delay exception, but the bill does not require it to do so.
  • Other residents: The bill does not directly change property rights, create a public hearing or appeal process, or require local governments to adopt mining ordinances.

Money#

The bill provides no estimate of public costs or savings.

  • It sets a $100 annual license fee per mine site in the text provided, but whether that is a new or existing fee is unclear. The fees go to the state’s environment and natural resources fee fund.
  • The bill does not provide funding or a staffing estimate. Local governments that choose to adopt and administer requirements may face costs; the amount is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • “Aggregate,” “substantially complied” and “administrative delay” are not defined in the supplied text.
  • The text does not set out local application steps, decision standards, timelines for local decisions, or appeal rights.
  • The supplied text for the existing mining-ordinance provision refers to local governments with both a comprehensive plan and zoning ordinances. Without the current statute or visible amendment marks, it is unclear whether HB 1288 changes that condition.
  • The bill does not explain how local requirements would interact with existing state or local mining rules beyond barring conflicts with state law and rules.
  • The supplied material gives no effective date. The bill’s passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that counties and municipalities could set local requirements suited to their area, while state law and rules remain the limit.
  • Requiring local permits before state approval could make local decisions matter in the state permitting process.
  • The 60-day conditional-permit option could let the state process move forward when an applicant has followed local procedures but is waiting on administrative action.
  • The ban on duplicative bonds or sureties could limit repeated financial requirements where state law or rules already require them.

Case against#

  • Local rules could differ among qualifying counties and municipalities, adding uncertainty for operators working in more than one area.
  • The bill does not define key terms or specify how local permit decisions must be made, which could leave important questions to local processes.
  • A conditional state permit could be issued before local permits are granted. Although mining could not start yet, the bill does not explain what happens if local permits are not obtained within 60 days.
  • The bill limits local authority to require additional bonds or sureties in some cases, which could restrict local financial safeguards.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1635173

    Passed10 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 7AGAINST · 3

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican7

    3Against

    • Republican3

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.