Recall measure would let voters oust officials

Summary#

HB 1315, titled “An Act to authorize the recall of certain elected officials or individuals appointed to fill vacancies in certain offices,” would add new sections to South Dakota’s existing Chapter 3-17. Its stated goal is to create a process to seek an official’s removal and elect a successor. The bill’s status listing says it was deferred to the 41st legislative day after a 9–2 vote; it is not law.

  • A petition would need signatures from 15% of the registered voters in the relevant jurisdiction, using the total at the last general election. Each signature would have to be no more than 60 days old when the petition is filed.
  • The petition would have to allege at least one of five grounds: crime or misdemeanor in office, drunkenness, gross incompetency, malfeasance, or misconduct. The bill does not define these terms.
  • If the Secretary of State finds the petition meets the stated requirements, the Secretary must certify it and order an election. The State Board of Elections must set the petition’s form by rule.
  • The election would choose whether the official is removed and who succeeds them. The incumbent may run; the candidate with the most votes would be elected. If no other candidate is nominated, no election would be held and the incumbent would stay in office.
  • The process would not apply to officers subject to impeachment under the state constitution.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: A qualifying group could start a recall petition for an elected official or a person appointed to fill a vacancy. The bill does not say that petition signers must prove the alleged ground before an election.
  • Officials targeted by a petition: They could run in the election. They would stay in office if no other candidate is nominated, if they win the election, or if a court rules in their favor on a challenge to the petition.
  • People challenging a petition: An interested person could challenge the petition’s filing or whether its statement of grounds is sufficient. That challenge must be brought in circuit court within five business days after the petition is presented. The court must hold an expedited hearing without a jury.
  • State election officials: The State Board of Elections must make rules for petition forms. The Secretary of State must certify qualifying petitions and order elections.
  • Current law: The materials do not include the current text of Chapter 3-17 or related election laws, so I could not verify whether any recall process already exists or exactly how this bill would change it.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires election officials to handle petitions and, when required, an election, but gives no estimate of staffing or election costs.
  • It does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define its grounds for recall, including “gross incompetency,” “malfeasance,” or “misconduct.”
  • It does not set an evidentiary standard for proving the alleged grounds before the election. It allows a court challenge to the sufficiency of the grounds stated in the petition.
  • It does not specify the ballot format or whether voters cast a separate yes-or-no vote on removal as well as choosing a successor.
  • The bill refers to existing laws for where petitions must be filed and how signature challenges work; those laws were not supplied, so their details could not be checked.
  • It does not explain how the signature threshold applies in practice to an appointed official’s jurisdiction.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give voters a way to seek an official’s removal for listed kinds of misconduct or incapacity.
  • A 15% signature threshold and a 60-day limit on signatures could be seen as safeguards against petitions based on too few or outdated signatures.
  • The process includes a court route to challenge a petition’s filing or the stated grounds before an election.
  • Including appointed vacancy-fillers means the process would not be limited to officials who won their office in an election.

Case against#

  • The grounds are not defined, which could leave room for disputes over what conduct qualifies.
  • A petition must allege a ground, but the bill does not require that the allegation be proven before the election.
  • The bill does not provide details on the ballot or set a separate vote threshold for removal; it says the candidate with the most votes is elected.
  • Requiring an election could create public costs, but the bill provides no estimate or funding plan.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1632011

    Passed11 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 9AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    9For

    • Republican8
    • Democratic1

    2Against

    • Republican2

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.