New permit could extend tax relief for facilities

Summary#

South Dakota SB-239 would amend the laws governing the reinvestment payment program; it did not become law, because the Senate reconsidered and failed it. Its stated goal, as described by its title, is to modify that program and rules for buying goods and services used by approved projects. The supplied text would add a special permit process for some large facilities, but does not include the bill’s purchasing provisions.

  • For qualifying new or expanded facilities, a person could apply for a combined reinvestment payment and direct payment permit. The Board of Economic Development could approve it by a two-thirds vote.
  • The Board would set the minimum project cost for this special process by policy and could not change that minimum within two years of setting it.
  • A permit could cover sales and use tax on the facility’s initial project cost and future equipment upgrades, for up to 30 years after construction starts.
  • A project cost would exclude costs attributable to processing, storing, retrieving, or communicating cryptocurrency-related data.
  • For a qualifying project, the Department of Revenue would assess direct payment permit eligibility before the Board reviews the application. A person found ineligible could not receive a permit through this special process.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and project owners: If a project meets the Board’s minimum cost and other requirements, its owner could apply for the special permit. Approval would not be automatic. The owner would need a direct payment permit, provide the required application information, and submit an annual affidavit listing equipment-upgrade costs after the project is complete.
  • Owners, lessees, and permit transferees: A permit could extend to a lessee or be assigned or transferred, but only if that person also holds a direct payment permit.
  • The Department of Revenue and Board of Economic Development: The Department would assess eligibility for a direct payment permit; the Board would decide whether to approve the reinvestment payment. The Secretary of Revenue would relieve the permit holder of certain tax-payment duties only to the extent covered by the reinvestment permit, and that relief would be deducted from the payment otherwise due.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The proposal would not guarantee approval or a payment to every project. The bill failed, so it made no change to current law.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The proposal could allow payments tied to sales and use tax on initial facility costs and later equipment upgrades, for up to 30 years. The payment could not exceed the tax due on those costs.
  • Tax-payment relief would reduce the reinvestment payment otherwise due; the text does not provide an estimate of total payments or revenue effects.
  • The proposal would require application review and annual affidavits, but the supplied material gives no staffing or administrative cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not include the bill’s provisions about purchasing goods and services, despite the title referring to them.
  • The current parent law was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which existing program rules the bill would change and which it would retain. The bill says other provisions of the reinvestment payment program would continue to apply, but those provisions are not included here.
  • The Board would set the minimum project cost, but the bill does not state the amount.
  • The supplied text does not explain the direct payment permit’s full eligibility rules or review process. It also says the usual appeal provisions would not apply to an application under this special process.
  • The bill text describes a 90-day Board decision period and factors the Board must consider, including whether the project would have happened without the payment. Without the current law, it is unclear which of these details would be new.
  • The supplied material does not explain how the special process would interact with other reinvestment payments or set an overall limit on commitments.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it could make tax-based support available for large facilities and later equipment upgrades, not just the initial project.
  • Requiring the Board to consider whether a project would have happened without the payment could help it focus support on projects that might not otherwise proceed.
  • Requiring direct payment permit eligibility and a two-thirds Board vote could add checks before a project receives this special treatment.

Case against#

  • One concern is that permits could cover future upgrades for as long as 30 years, while the supplied text gives no estimate of the total public cost.
  • The minimum project cost would be set by Board policy, not by an amount written into the bill. The bill does not state how the Board should choose that amount.
  • The special application would not have the appeal provisions referenced for direct payment permits, but the supplied text does not explain what review or remedy would remain.
  • The supplied text does not include the purchasing rules named in the title, so their effects cannot be assessed.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1643168

    Defeated33 members voted

    Reconsidered

    AGAINST · 17FOR · 16

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    17Against

    • Republican15
    • Democratic2

    16For

    • Republican15
    • Democratic1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1641821

    Passed33 members voted

    Do Pass Amended

    FOR · 17AGAINST · 16

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    17For

    • Republican15
    • Democratic2

    16Against

    • Republican15
    • Democratic1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1638540

    Passed9 members voted

    Do Pass Amended

    FOR · 6AGAINST · 3

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    6For

    • Republican5
    • Democratic1

    3Against

    • Republican3