New tax funds property tax relief

Summary#

SB 243 would create a new transaction-tax chapter and amend several existing South Dakota tax laws; it does not replace the property-tax system. Its stated goal is to use the new tax’s revenue to reduce certain property taxes, starting with owner-occupied single-family homes.

  • The tax would apply to each retail transaction that generates gross receipts taxable under Chapter 10-45. It would be $1.50 for a transaction priced at $15 or more, and 10% of the price below $15.
  • A purchase of multiple items at the same time by the same person would count as one transaction if the price includes all the items.
  • The Department of Revenue would run a continuously appropriated property tax replacement fund. Revenue would pay for distributions to local governments and the cost of administering the tax.
  • The Department would allocate money to reduce property-tax levies in this order: owner-occupied single-family homes; agricultural property; then nonagricultural property. Reductions would be in equal proportions across counties within each category, and would stop when that category’s taxes reached zero or the available money ran out.
  • People who must file and pay taxes under Chapter 10-45 would generally file and pay this tax monthly. Late payment can bring existing tax penalties and interest; failure to pay within 60 days would be a misdemeanor, and a false return intended to evade the tax would be a felony.

What it means for you#

  • People making purchases: The bill would add a tax to covered transactions. It does not say that every purchase is covered; coverage depends on what is taxable under Chapter 10-45.
  • People who own property: Your property taxes would be reduced only if money is available for your property category. Homeowners with owner-occupied single-family homes would be first in line; agricultural property and then nonagricultural property would follow.
  • Businesses and other Chapter 10-45 tax filers: You would generally have to report and pay the tax to the Department of Revenue. The bill does not expressly say how the tax must be shown to customers, though it allows contractors to list it separately on contracts and bills.
  • Local governments: The fund could provide money for ordinary and capital expenses, while the Department’s allocation process would reduce specified property-tax levies.
  • The public: The bill would not abolish property taxes. Its reductions depend on fund revenue and are limited by the order and stopping points in the bill.

Money#

The bill provides no estimate of revenue, public cost, or property-tax reductions.

  • The tax would raise money for the replacement fund, which would also cover the cost of administering the tax.
  • The fund would be continuously appropriated, but the bill gives no estimate of the amounts to be collected or distributed.
  • The bill does not estimate how much property taxes would fall, or whether the fund would contain enough money to reach the later property categories.

What is unclear#

  • The parent laws are not supplied, so the available material does not show which goods and services are currently taxable under Chapter 10-45 or how this tax would interact with all existing taxes.
  • The bill gives no start date, and does not set out a process for calculating the tax on transactions involving discounts, refunds, or other complications.
  • Section 2 refers to a “property tax relief fund,” while the fund created in the bill is called the “property tax replacement fund.” The text does not explain whether these names mean the same fund.
  • The bill does not explain how local governments would receive distributions for ordinary and capital expenses while the Department also uses the fund to reduce property-tax levies.
  • The supplied status says the bill was deferred to the 41st legislative day after a 4–3 vote. It is not law, and the text gives no effective date.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to shift some funding away from property taxes and toward a tax on covered retail transactions.
  • A possible argument for the priority order is that it directs available money first to owner-occupied single-family homes, before agricultural and nonagricultural property.
  • The fund could also help local governments pay ordinary and capital expenses, while setting aside money to administer the new tax.

Case against#

  • The new tax would add a charge to covered purchases, while the amount of property-tax relief would depend on how much revenue the fund receives.
  • The $1.50 charge on transactions of $15 or more is a fixed amount, so it takes up a smaller share of the price as the transaction becomes more expensive.
  • Later property categories could receive no reduction if earlier categories use all available money.
  • The bill does not provide revenue or cost estimates, explain the fund-name mismatch, or set out detailed rules for applying and overseeing the tax.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1640173

    Passed5 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 4AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    4For

    • Republican4

    1Against

    • Republican1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.