Summary#
The Commercial Organisations and Public Authorities Duty (Human Rights and Environment) Bill [HL] is a private member’s bill that would create a new law; the supplied material does not show it amending an existing Act. Its stated goal is to require commercial organisations and public authorities to prevent human rights and environmental harms through due diligence (steps to identify and address risks). The bill is at the House of Lords’ second-reading stage, so it is not law and passage is uncertain.
- Commercial organisations would have duties covering their own operations, subsidiaries and value chains. The bill refers to human rights and environmental due diligence, including reviewing and improving measures, communicating with stakeholders and reporting publicly.
- Public authorities would have duties in procurement (how they buy goods and services). The extract says that, in each procurement, the supplier would bear the burden of proof; it does not provide the full rule.
- The bill would require reporting and transparency, including reports on due diligence and searchable disclosure of ownership structures and human rights and environmental assessments.
- It provides for an enforcement body, civil liability and penalties. The stated maximum fine is up to 10% of an organisation’s global turnover.
- It also includes a criminal offence linked to certain serious offences—such as murder, kidnapping, false imprisonment and rape—when committed to obtain or retain business for an organisation. The supplied extract does not give the full conditions or penalties for that offence.
What it means for you#
- Businesses: If enacted, commercial organisations would have to take due diligence steps across their operations, subsidiaries and value chains. The bill also provides for liability and penalties, but the exact tests and procedures are not clear from the supplied extract.
- Public authorities and suppliers: Public authorities would have to apply the bill’s procurement duties. The extract places the burden of proof on suppliers in each procurement, but does not explain what they must prove or how.
- People harmed by business activity: The bill provides for civil claims and remedies, including orders to clean up harm or restore what was lost. It also refers to access to justice, but the supplied extract does not set out the full process.
- Directors and other responsible people: The bill includes provisions on their liability, but the extract does not show when they would be liable or what penalties would apply.
- General public: The bill does not itself guarantee that harms will be prevented. It would create duties and enforcement mechanisms intended to address them.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill proposes fines of up to 10% of an organisation’s global turnover, but the supplied material gives no estimate of likely fines or how often they might be imposed.
- The bill provides for an enforcement body, but the available material gives no staffing or operating cost.
- No publicly available information on the costs of due diligence, reporting or procurement requirements.
What is unclear#
- The supplied bill text is incomplete. It does not show the full definitions, duties, enforcement powers, or conditions for civil and criminal liability.
- The extract does not identify how the enforcement body would be formed, what cases it could investigate, or how its decisions could be challenged.
- It does not set out the process for civil claims, including deadlines, evidence rules or who could bring a claim.
- The extract lists environmental harms, but does not show how human rights harms are defined or whether key terms are defined elsewhere in the bill.
- The definition of “public authority” is incomplete in the supplied material. The bill’s relationship with existing laws and programs also cannot be checked because the relevant current laws were not supplied.
- The bill says it would come into force on the day it is passed. It does not show whether any transition period or later rules would apply.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make organisations address harm in their own operations and across subsidiaries and value chains, rather than focus only on their direct activities.
- Requiring due diligence, public reporting and ownership disclosure could make organisations’ actions more visible and give the public information about how they respond to risks.
- Civil remedies and an enforcement body could provide routes to address harm beyond relying on voluntary action.
- Applying duties to public procurement could let public authorities consider human rights and environmental harms when buying goods and services.
Case against#
- The bill’s duties and enforcement rules are not fully clear from the supplied text. Organisations and public authorities may not know what compliance requires until further rules or guidance are available.
- The bill would create broad duties across value chains, but the extract does not explain how responsibility would be divided when several organisations are involved.
- Civil liability, director liability and fines of up to 10% of global turnover could be serious consequences, while the available material does not show the safeguards, decision process or appeal rights.
- The bill does not show how the enforcement body would be funded or whether it would have enough staff to carry out its functions.