E-Scooters (Safety and Sale) Bill [HL]

Summary#

The E-Scooters (Safety and Sale) Bill [HL] is a private member’s bill that would create a new law, not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to set safety and sales rules for e-scooters; it is not law, and the supplied material says it is at second reading in the House of Lords.

  • The Secretary of State must make regulations setting safety requirements for e-scooters offered for sale. These must cover maximum speed and power, braking, lighting and visibility, and construction standards.
  • The bill would prohibit marketing, selling or supplying e-scooters for use on roads or other public places where that use is unlawful. “Marketing” includes promotional material, product descriptions and other communications to customers.
  • It would prohibit selling or supplying equipment that could modify an e-scooter to get around safety requirements, where the modification affects speed, power, braking or safety systems.
  • It would make provision for consumer information rules and enforcement by trading standards officers and police constables. The supplied text also lists seizure and penalties, but does not provide their operative details.
  • The bill would extend to England, Wales and Scotland.

What it means for you#

  • Retailers and suppliers: If the bill became law, they would face the sales and marketing prohibitions and any consumer information rules made under it. The supplied text does not say what information must be given or how the prohibitions would be applied.
  • E-scooter buyers and users: The bill does not itself make e-scooter use lawful in places where it is currently unlawful, nor does it set out a direct ban on buying all e-scooters. It would set safety requirements for scooters offered for sale.
  • Manufacturers and sellers of modification equipment: They would be barred from supplying equipment capable of certain modifications that circumvent the prescribed safety requirements.
  • Enforcement officers: Trading standards officers and constables would receive enforcement powers, but the supplied text does not show what those powers are.
  • Current law: No parent Act is identified because this is a proposed new law. The materials do not include the current rules on where e-scooters may be used, so I cannot verify how the proposed sales ban would apply to particular uses.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Secretary of State to make regulations, but no staffing or implementation costs are given.
  • No figures are provided for enforcement, seizure, penalties, business compliance costs, or any fees or revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text is incomplete: it gives headings for consumer information, seizure and penalties, but not the rules under those headings.
  • The exact speed, power and other safety limits are not set out; they would have to be specified in later regulations.
  • The bill does not explain how sellers’ intended use of a scooter would be assessed, or what evidence would show that it was marketed for unlawful use.
  • The supplied text does not give the start date, the process for making regulations, or any appeal or oversight arrangements.
  • The current legal rules on e-scooter use are not included, so the exact reach of the sales and marketing prohibition cannot be checked against them.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to set minimum safety requirements for e-scooters sold to the public. Requiring rules for speed, power, braking, lighting, visibility and construction could give sellers and buyers a defined safety standard.
  • Prohibiting equipment that circumvents those standards could help prevent the safety rules from being bypassed.
  • Consumer information rules and enforcement powers could support compliance, although their details are not in the supplied text.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves the actual safety limits to later regulations. Until those are set, the main standards buyers and sellers would have to follow are unknown.
  • The sales and marketing prohibition depends on where use is unlawful, but the bill text supplied does not explain how sellers must determine the intended use or how the rule would work in practice.
  • The bill mentions seizure and penalties without showing their scope or limits. That makes it hard to judge the consequences for sellers and owners of non-compliant scooters.
  • The bill would require regulations and create enforcement responsibilities, but gives no cost estimate or detail on the resources needed.