Impact Fees Tied to Fixture Counts

Summary#

HB-570, “New Home Impact Fee Amendments,” would amend Utah Code section 11-36a-305, which covers calculating impact fees. It would require local political subdivisions and private entities to use the number of plumbing fixtures shown in building plans when calculating the proportionate share for a single-family residential development activity. The stated goal is to modify how those impact fees are calculated. The bill failed, so it did not take effect; it proposed an effective date of May 6, 2026.

  • The bill defines a “plumbing fixture” as a receptacle or device connected to a water supply system, a drainage system, or both.
  • The fixture-count rule would apply to single-family residential use development activities. It does not set a fee amount or say that an impact fee must be charged.
  • The bill’s text also requires realistic estimates for impact-fee calculations and disclosure of the assumptions behind them. I cannot verify against the current law whether this requirement would change.
  • The bill does not create a new agency or a process for submitting plans, reviewing fee calculations, or appealing them.

What it means for you#

  • Local political subdivisions and private entities that calculate these impact fees: If the bill had become law, they would have had to use the fixture count shown in the building plans to determine the development activity’s proportionate share.
  • People building or buying a single-family home: The calculation of an applicable impact fee could have been affected by the number of fixtures shown in the plans. The bill does not say how that count would translate into a dollar amount.
  • Other development activities: The fixture-count rule is written for single-family residential use. The bill does not directly change how other types of development are calculated.

Money#

No appropriation is included, and no estimate of implementation costs is provided.

  • Local political subdivisions and private entities would have to use the fixture-count method for the covered calculations, but the bill gives no cost estimate for any added work.
  • The bill does not set new fees, change listed allowable costs, or provide a fee amount.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give a formula for turning the fixture count into a proportionate share or a dollar amount.
  • It does not say how fixtures would be counted if plans change, or what happens if plans do not show the relevant information.
  • The definition of “plumbing fixture” is broad; the bill does not explain how different kinds of devices would be counted.
  • The current version of Utah Code section 11-36a-305 was not supplied, so I could not independently verify which existing requirements the bill would change beyond the edits shown in the bill text.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that fixture counts shown in building plans provide a concrete basis for calculating each covered development activity’s share.
  • Using a stated count could make calculations easier to explain and compare, while the bill’s text also calls for realistic estimates and disclosure of assumptions.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not explain how fixture counts should be converted into fees, leaving a key part of the calculation unclear.
  • Counting fixtures may not capture every difference in the effects of different homes on system improvements. The bill does not explain why fixture count is the right measure.
  • The bill relies on building plans but creates no process for handling missing or changed plans, or for challenging a calculation.