State remedy for constitutional rights violations

Summary#

HB 577, “State-Created Remedies for Federal Constitutional Violations,” would create a new section of Utah law. Its stated goal is to provide a state-law remedy when a person’s rights under the U.S. Constitution are violated by a government employee or agent. The bill failed, so it did not become law.

  • A person who is a Utah citizen or within Utah’s jurisdiction and is injured could sue an individual government employee or agent if that person’s conduct under government authority caused a violation of federal constitutional rights.
  • The remedy would be available only if the injured person could not seek relief against that individual under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 or another statute providing a remedy for a federal constitutional violation.
  • A court could award compensatory damages, equitable relief (such as an order requiring or stopping an action), and reasonable attorney fees and costs. Punitive damages would be barred.
  • The lawsuit could be brought against an individual, not a federal, state, or local government entity. The bill says it would not impose liability on those entities.
  • If enacted, it would apply to claims arising on or after May 6, 2026, and would take effect that day.

What it means for you#

  • People injured by government employees or agents: The bill would offer a state-law route to seek relief, but only if you could not seek relief under another statute covering the constitutional violation. It would not allow punitive damages.
  • Federal, state, and local employees or agents: You could be sued as an individual if your conduct under government authority caused the covered violation. The bill does not make the government entity itself liable under this new section.
  • Government entities and taxpayers: The bill would not authorize a lawsuit against a government entity under this section. It makes no appropriation, but the materials do not estimate other possible financial effects.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it does not currently create this right to sue.

Money#

The bill appropriates no money, and the available materials give no cost estimate.

  • A court could order an individual defendant to pay compensatory damages and reasonable attorney fees and costs.
  • The bill would bar punitive damages.
  • It does not authorize awards against government entities under this section.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “injured,” “under color of” government law, or what it means that a person “could seek relief” under another statute.
  • It does not explain how courts should decide whether another statutory remedy is available, or how this new remedy would interact with those remedies.
  • The supplied materials do not include the relevant current-law text or explain how these terms relate to existing law. No publicly available information.
  • The bill sets an accrual date but does not explain how that date would apply in particular cases.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to provide a way to seek relief when other statutory routes for a federal constitutional violation are unavailable.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let injured people seek compensation or court orders, and could allow recovery of reasonable legal costs.
  • The remedy would reach individual employees or agents of federal, state, and local government, rather than only one level of government.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the exception for cases where a person “could seek relief” under another statute may make it uncertain which cases qualify.
  • The bill does not define key terms or explain how courts should apply the exception, leaving important parts of the remedy unclear.
  • A possible trade-off is that the bill would allow claims against individual employees or agents but expressly exclude government entities from liability under this section.