Supreme Court Referendum Would Delay Unconstitutional Opinions

Summary#

HB 600, Utah Supreme Court Referendum Amendments, failed and did not become law. It would have amended Utah election laws and added a process for voters to approve or reject a Utah Supreme Court opinion holding a state law unconstitutional; the bill’s stated goal was to create that referendum process.

  • The process would apply only to Supreme Court opinions finding a state law unconstitutional. The bill defines “state law” to include a state statute, a provision of the Utah Constitution, or an action of the Legislature.
  • At least five registered Utah voters would have to sponsor an application, filed within a short deadline after the opinion is issued. To qualify for a vote, a petition would need signatures from 8% of active voters statewide and 8% in at least 15 Senate districts.
  • The lieutenant governor and county clerks would have duties to publish petition information and assess and certify signatures. If enough signatures were certified, the governor would direct a vote at the next regular general election or call a special election.
  • Once enough signatures were certified, the opinion would be stayed (temporarily prevented from taking effect). At the election, a majority voting “For” would put the opinion into effect; a majority voting “Against” would mean it did not take effect.
  • Sponsors would have to arrange and pay for printing the petition materials. The bill prohibits paying people to sign or remove their signatures, but does not prohibit paying people to gather signatures.

What it means for you#

  • Utah voters: Under the proposal, registered voters could sign a paper petition and vote on a qualifying opinion. The bill does not allow electronic signatures.
  • Petition sponsors: Sponsors would have to meet the filing and signature rules, and pay printing costs. The lieutenant governor would determine whether a petition qualified.
  • State and county election officials: They would have new petition, voter-information, ballot and election duties. The bill did not set out all the procedures for carrying them out.
  • People affected by a Supreme Court opinion: If the signature threshold were reached, the opinion would be stayed while the process continued. The bill does not directly explain what would happen to the underlying state law if voters rejected the opinion.
  • Current law: The bill failed, so it created no referendum process. The supplied materials do not include the full current text of the amended laws, so I could not verify all existing petition and election rules that would interact with it.

Money#

The bill appropriated no money, but it would have added duties for public officials; no cost estimate is provided.

  • Sponsors would pay to print the petition materials.
  • No publicly available information on the added staffing, administration or election costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill sets a 106-day point for the lieutenant governor to decide whether a petition is sufficient, but the supplied text does not clearly state the deadline for submitting all signatures.
  • The bill does not explain how rejecting an opinion would affect the underlying law, other court orders, or cases already decided.
  • It does not provide a full process for any special election or explain how the new process would interact with existing referendum rules.
  • No cost estimate or staffing plan is included.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives voters a direct way to approve or reject a Supreme Court determination that a state law is unconstitutional.
  • The signature thresholds would require substantial support across the state and across at least 15 Senate districts before an election could be triggered.
  • The bill provides for an impartial short title and summary, voter information, and a court process to challenge wording alleged to be false or biased.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a referendum could delay the effect of a Supreme Court opinion, including after the petition reaches the required signature threshold.
  • The bill does not clearly explain the legal consequences if voters reject the opinion, particularly for the underlying law and affected cases.
  • The process would add work for election officials and could require a special election, but the bill provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.