Public employee defense fees bill dies

Summary#

SB-316, Public Employee Attorney Fee Recovery Amendments, would have repealed and reenacted Utah Code Section 52-6-201. Its stated goal was to allow courts to order certain public entities to pay a public employee’s reasonable defense fees and court costs when the entities acted in bad faith. The supplied status says the bill failed, so it did not take effect.

  • A court could order payment only if the criminal charge was connected to the employee’s public work, was quashed or dismissed or ended in acquittal, and the court found a public entity acted in bad faith.
  • The covered entities could include the employee’s public employer and the prosecutor’s office that pursued the charge.
  • An employee could not recover under this provision if found guilty of another violation of law for substantially the same act or omission.
  • If both the employer-side entity and the prosecuting office acted in bad faith, the court could order each to pay half of the fees and costs.

What it means for you#

  • Public employees: Because the bill failed, it gives you no new right to recover fees. Under the proposal, recovery would have depended on the listed conditions and a court’s finding of bad faith.
  • Public entities and prosecutors: The failed bill creates no new payment duty. Under the proposal, a court could have ordered a covered entity to pay reasonable fees and court costs necessarily incurred in the employee’s defense.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill appropriates no money. If it had taken effect, payments ordered by a court could have been a cost to the public entity involved.

Money#

No money is appropriated, but the proposal could have required public entities to pay court-ordered defense fees and costs.

  • The bill gives no estimate of how often payments might be ordered or how much they might total.
  • It does not set a fee amount; a court would decide what fees and costs were reasonable and necessary.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of Section 52-6-201, so I could not verify how much of the proposed wording would have changed current law.
  • The bill does not define “bad faith.”
  • It does not explain how a court should decide which entity acted in bad faith when more than one entity was involved. It says each must pay half if both specified entities acted in bad faith.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that an employee who defeats a work-related criminal charge should not have to bear defense costs when a public entity acted in bad faith.
  • Requiring a court to find bad faith, and limiting recovery to reasonable and necessary costs, would restrict payment to cases meeting those conditions.
  • The proposal identifies both the employee’s public employer and the office that pursued the charge as possible sources of payment.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define “bad faith,” leaving an important condition open to a court’s interpretation.
  • A possible concern is that public entities could face unpredictable costs because the bill provides no estimate or limit on the total fees and costs a court could order.
  • The proposal’s wording does not clearly explain how responsibility would be handled if more than one entity was involved but only one was found to have acted in bad faith.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1650882

    Passed27 members voted

    Senate/ passed 3rd reading

    FOR · 26AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    26For

    • Republican19
    • Democratic6
    • Independent1

    1Against

    • Republican1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1648501

    Passed6 members voted

    Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation

    FOR · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    6For

    • Republican5
    • Democratic1

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1649329

    Passed22 members voted

    Senate/ passed 2nd reading

    FOR · 20AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    20For

    • Republican14
    • Democratic5
    • Independent1

    2Against

    • Republican2

    7 members were paired and sat out the vote.