Trail designation rules would govern trails

Summary#

HB 595, “Public Trail Amendments,” would have added four sections to Utah law to create a process for designating and managing state trails. Its stated goal is to address how recreational trails are designated as state trails. The bill failed, so it did not take effect.

  • A person could apply to designate an existing recreational trail on public land. The Division of Outdoor Recreation would have to evaluate a completed application, send it for review to specified local and state officials and the Utah Outdoor Recreation Infrastructure Advisory Committee, and report the evaluation and comments to a legislative committee.
  • A county or municipality could block the committee from recommending a trail by adopting a resolution opposing it. The committee also could not recommend a trail if it might cause a state agency to breach a legal obligation over land in the proposed trail area.
  • The Legislature and governor would designate a state trail by concurrent resolution. The bill also says they may act despite the requirements in the application and review section.
  • The Division could assess private or federal land for possible purchase, transfer, or lease to the state and negotiate for it, as appropriations allow. The bill does not require a landowner to transfer land.
  • The Division would manage designated trails and could contract for management services. If the specified Utah Public Land Management Act takes effect, the government entity responsible for the public land would instead manage the trail.

What it means for you#

  • People applying: Any person could submit an application, but the bill does not set the application details itself. The Division would set them by rule.
  • Counties, municipalities, legislators, and state agencies: When a completed application is received, the Division would have to send it to the applicable entities or officials for review. A county or municipality’s opposing resolution would prevent a committee recommendation, subject to the bill’s separate provision allowing the Legislature and governor to act despite the application-section requirements.
  • Private landowners and federal agencies: The Division could evaluate land and negotiate a possible sale, transfer, or lease to the state. The bill does not require an owner or agency to agree.
  • People using public trails: A state trail would have to be on public land and limited to the smallest area compatible with its proper care and management. The bill does not itself establish public access rules.
  • Everyone: The bill would create a designation and management structure, not a guaranteed new trail or a new front-line service.

Money#

The bill appropriates no money, and no implementation cost estimate is provided.

  • The Division could negotiate for land only “as appropriations allow.”
  • The bill would assign management duties to the Division, but does not state how many staff or how much funding would be needed.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what makes an application complete or set timelines for evaluation and review; it leaves application rules to the Division.
  • It does not explain how the Legislature and governor would use the power to act despite the application-section requirements, including whether that could bypass the limits on committee recommendations.
  • It does not set public access, maintenance, or other operating rules for a state trail; the Division may make management rules.
  • It does not explain how the trail designation would interact with other trail programs or existing land-management rules. The current code was not supplied, so those overlaps could not be checked.
  • It is unclear when the Utah Public Land Management Act referenced in the bill would take effect. The bill makes that event the condition for management to pass to the government entity responsible for the land.

Case for#

  • A formal process could give the Division a way to evaluate proposed trails and collect views from affected local governments, legislators, and state agencies.
  • Requiring a trail to be on public land and confined to the smallest area compatible with its care and management could limit the area designated.
  • Allowing the Division to negotiate for land could provide a way to pursue a trail route where existing public land is insufficient, without requiring a transfer.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set application timelines, evaluation standards, or detailed management rules, so important parts of the process would be left to later rulemaking.
  • The Legislature and governor’s ability to act despite the application-section requirements could weaken the role of the application, review, and committee process. The bill does not clearly explain the limits of that power.
  • The bill assigns management duties without providing funding or estimating the staffing and other costs.
  • The bill does not explain how trail designation would affect existing land uses or how the public would be involved beyond the listed reviews.