City fast-tracks landfill work with four bidders

Summary#

Vancouver City Council approved the Landfill Gas and Closure Construction Program 2 (LCCP2), a three-year City contracting program for landfill gas, closure and related construction work. It authorizes staff to invite four pre-qualified contractors to compete for projects with an estimated total cost of $34.4 million, plus applicable taxes. City staff say the goal is to speed up contracting and improve the bids received.

  • The four pre-qualified contractors are KBL Projects Ltd., Jacob Bros. Construction Ltd., BD Hall Constructors Corp. and King Hoe Excavating Ltd.
  • The City must invite these contractors to bid on projects as work is needed. The contractor with the lowest bid is to receive each project; the staff report says the bid must also be compliant.
  • Council delegated authority to the Chief Procurement Officer to sign participation agreements, and to the General Manager of Engineering and Chief Procurement Officer to sign construction agreements.
  • Individual awards will go through the City’s Contract Approval Summary process, with Engineering and Finance leadership approval, but will not return to the Bid Committee or Council.
  • Council’s approval alone creates no legal rights or obligations; the agreements must first be signed and delivered.

What it means for you#

  • The four selected contractors: They may be invited to bid on at least three project tenders over the program’s three-year term. Pre-qualification does not guarantee them work.
  • Other contractors: They are not on the list of firms invited to bid under this program.
  • Residents and taxpayers: The decision sets up a way to procure landfill work. It does not create a new tax, fee or direct public service.

Money#

The program’s estimated project cost is $34.4 million over three years, plus applicable taxes.

  • Funding is to come from capital project budgets. Finance must confirm funding for each project before procurement starts.
  • The report says some funding is in the approved 2023–2026 Capital Budget; remaining funding is expected from similar programs in the 2027–2030 Capital Plan, based on available approved funding.
  • No separate estimate for administering the program is given.

What is unclear#

  • The exact projects, schedules and amounts for individual contracts are not set out. The report mentions two routine landfill gas tenders, one closure tender and possible stormwater work.
  • The decision does not guarantee that all estimated work will proceed or that the full $34.4 million will be spent.
  • The materials do not give a separate estimate of the time or cost saved.

Case for#

  • City staff say the program could shorten procurement by about six weeks per project and help coordinate work with the landfill filling plan.
  • Staff cite regulatory requirements for collecting landfill gas and applying final cover, as well as schedule commitments linked to provincial funding.
  • The four firms were selected after evaluation that included experience, safety, staffing capacity and Indigenous participation, employment equity and workforce diversity.

Case against#

  • The decision removes individual Council and Bid Committee approval for contracts under the program, even though staff expect each to exceed $3 million.
  • The report says earlier contracting had problems with safety incidents, construction quality, deadlines, supplier management and high prices. The new process does not guarantee those problems will be resolved.
  • The program limits invitations to four firms. The materials do not explain how many will bid on each project or what will happen if no compliant bid is received.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 11783

    Passed10 members voted

    Standing Committee on City Finance and Services: Report 9. Contract Award - Pre-qualified Contractors for Gas, Closure, and Other Landfill Work

    FOR · 10

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    10For

    • ABC Vancouver7
    • COPE1
    • OneCity Vancouver1
    • Vote Vancouver1

    0Against