City rezones to 26-storey rental tower

Summary#

Council approved in principle the rezoning at 1088 West 12th Avenue, on the southeast corner of West 12th Avenue and Spruce Street in Fairview. It would change the site from R3-3 Residential to CD-1 (Comprehensive Development, a site-specific zoning), increasing the maximum height and density. The stated goal is to allow a 26-storey mixed-use rental building with commercial space and below-market rental homes.

  • The approved-in-principle plan has 304 rental homes: 246 market rental and 58 below-market rental. At least 20% of the residential floor area must be below-market.
  • The maximum height would rise from 27.5 metres to 81 metres (265 feet), and the maximum floor space ratio (FSR, building floor area compared with site area) from 3.0 to 6.9.
  • All 304 homes would be secured by a Housing Agreement and covenant for at least 60 years or the life of the building, whichever is longer.
  • Council also approved in principle related Sign By-law and Noise Control By-law changes, subject to the CD-1 by-law. A Housing Agreement by-law must be enacted before the CD-1 by-law.
  • The rezoning is not yet in force: it takes effect only if Council later enacts the CD-1 by-law. The decision says it does not require the City to enact it.

What it means for you#

  • Current tenants: The site has 65 existing rental homes. City staff say 58 tenancies meet the City’s Tenant Relocation and Protection Policy requirements. Eligible tenants are to have a right of first refusal to return at the lower of their current rent or 20% below the city-wide average market rent. The report does not say that every existing tenant qualifies.
  • Future renters: The plan includes 58 below-market homes. Their starting rents at initial tenancy and turnover would be 20% below city-wide average market rents. The report does not establish that these rents would be affordable to every household.
  • Nearby residents: If built as proposed, the project would replace the current three-storey building with a 26-storey building and ground-floor commercial uses. The proposal includes two underground parking levels; parking and loading details are to be settled at the development-permit stage.
  • Residents generally: The decision approves the project in principle, not construction itself. Conditions and later by-law enactment remain necessary.

Money#

The report estimates project-related charges and a public-art contribution, but gives no estimate of City administrative or infrastructure costs.

  • The applicant requested a waiver of City-wide Development Cost Levies (DCLs). The report expects $2,802,348 in DCLs to be paid and estimates the value of the requested residential DCL waiver at $4,148,022.
  • No Community Amenity Contribution is anticipated, based on the cost of securing the rental homes.
  • The estimated public-art contribution is $426,740, using the current (2016) rate.

What is unclear#

  • The CD-1 by-law has not yet been enacted; the project may not proceed as approved in principle.
  • The report says final parking, loading and bicycle spaces will be set at the development-permit stage.
  • The final number of trees to be removed or planted is not settled; staff say it will be confirmed at the development-permit stage.
  • The materials do not give the City’s cost for processing conditions or providing infrastructure, or say how the requested DCL waiver will be resolved.

Case for#

  • City staff say the site’s 76.2-metre frontage allows consideration of up to 26 storeys under the Broadway Plan, and that the proposed height is consistent with the Plan.
  • The project would add 304 secured rental homes, including 58 below-market homes, in a location near Vancouver General Hospital and the planned Oak-VGH SkyTrain station.
  • Staff say the extra density would allow larger commercial units and more efficient floor plates, without unduly affecting neighbouring sites.
  • Of 77 online comments, 42 supported the project; comments cited rental housing, its location and ground-floor retail.

Case against#

  • Residents raised concerns that the 26-storey height and larger tower floor plates would not fit the area’s existing low-rise character.
  • Residents also raised the risk that tenants could be displaced and that new homes may not be affordable to people living in the existing building. The plan includes relocation protections for eligible tenants, but does not guarantee that every current tenant can return.
  • Residents raised concerns about traffic, parking and pressure on infrastructure. Staff say required parking and traffic-safety measures will be addressed through later requirements, including a proposed pedestrian-and-cyclist signal at West 12th Avenue and Spruce Street.
  • Of the 77 online comments, 26 opposed the project and 9 were mixed.