Presume competence for communication resources

Summary#

H.R. 17 is a Vermont House resolution, not a bill amending an Act. It affirms the House’s view that all Vermonters are presumed competent to communicate and must have effective communication resources of their choice; its stated aim is to affirm that principle. The supplied status says the resolution was adopted.

  • It directs the House Clerk to send a copy to the existing Vermont Communication Task Force.
  • It does not create a new organization or operating program. The resolution describes the Task Force as an existing network that provides guidance, policy recommendations, research monitoring and training in developmental disability services.
  • It says the Rapid Prompting Method may be a beneficial communication option, but does not require anyone to use it.
  • It does not set out an enforceable service process, funding, or standards for deciding what resources are effective. The materials do not establish what current law already requires.

What it means for you#

  • Vermonters who use communication support: The resolution affirms that you should be presumed competent and receive effective resources of your choice. It does not itself establish how to obtain those resources or enforce that statement.
  • The Vermont Communication Task Force: It would receive a copy. The resolution does not assign it new duties or change its described role.
  • State agencies, service providers and taxpayers: The resolution does not directly impose new service duties, create a benefit, or set a charge or payment.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution provides no appropriation, cost estimate, staffing requirement or funding source.
  • Its only direct instruction is for the House Clerk to send the resolution to the Task Force.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define “effective communication resources” or explain how a person’s choice would be handled if others disagree about a method.
  • It sets no standards, application process, timelines, appeals or enforcement.
  • It does not say whether the Task Force’s work, staffing or funding would change.
  • The supplied material does not show how the resolution relates to existing legal duties or services.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the resolution is that communication challenges should not be treated as proof that a person lacks intellectual competence.
  • Affirming a person’s choice of communication resources could focus attention on providing the support, training and technology needed for participation.
  • The resolution points to an existing Task Force and regional specialists that already provide guidance and training in developmental disability services.

Case against#

  • The resolution says resources “must” be provided, but does not create a process or enforcement mechanism to make that happen.
  • It affirms a choice of effective resources without defining effectiveness or explaining how disagreements would be resolved.
  • It notes that the Rapid Prompting Method may be beneficial but gives no criteria for assessing or selecting it.