“Shall” Would Mean Mandatory in Statutes

Summary#

HB 1299, titled “Rules of construction; use of ‘shall,’ effective clause, report,” would amend the Code of Virginia by adding a rule about how to read the word “shall” in a statute. The stated purpose is to make “shall” a mandatory requirement unless the statute expressly provides otherwise. The bill has passed the Virginia House of Delegates but is not law.

  • Courts and others interpreting Virginia statutes would have to treat “shall” as mandatory, not merely directory (that is, not merely guidance), unless the statute expressly says otherwise.
  • This is a rule for interpreting statutes; it does not itself set out a new service, benefit, fine, or specific duty for a named person or group.
  • The supplied House-engrossed text puts provisions requiring reenactment and a Virginia Code Commission review and report in brackets. They appear to have been removed from the operative bill text.

What it means for you#

  • People and organizations subject to Virginia statutes: If a statute says someone “shall” do something, the new rule would treat that as mandatory unless that statute expressly provides otherwise. The bill does not identify particular statutes or obligations.
  • Courts and public officials applying statutes: They would have a new rule of construction for interpreting “shall.” The bill does not create a process for applications, reviews, or appeals.
  • General public: The bill does not directly create a new benefit, ban, fee, or penalty. The effect would depend on how the rule applies to existing statutes.
  • Status: The bill has passed the House, but passage is uncertain and the supplied text does not state when it would take effect.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The operative text does not specify spending, staffing, fees, fines, or savings.
  • The supplied text brackets a proposed Virginia Code Commission review and report; it does not appear in the operative bill text.

What is unclear#

  • The current Code of Virginia is not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how existing rules already treat “shall” or how much this bill would change current law.
  • The bill does not explain how to decide whether a statute “expressly provides otherwise.”
  • The operative text does not give an effective date.
  • The title refers to an effective clause and a report, but the related provisions are bracketed in the supplied House-engrossed text and appear to have been removed.

Case for#

  • A clear default rule could make statutory requirements easier to interpret consistently.
  • Treating “shall” as mandatory could reduce uncertainty about whether a stated requirement must be followed.
  • The exception for statutes that expressly provide otherwise leaves room for lawmakers to state a different rule in a particular statute.

Case against#

  • One concern is that treating “shall” as mandatory could change how existing statutes operate, but the supplied material does not show which statutes would be affected.
  • The bill does not define what counts as an express exception, which could leave disputes about how the rule applies.
  • The House-engrossed text appears to remove a proposed review of effects on existing law, so the operative text does not require that review or a report.