Courts Must Weigh Officials’ Legal Advice

Summary#

HB 160 would amend Virginia’s Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), changing what courts must consider when deciding whether public officials knowingly and willfully violated FOIA. Its stated aim is to make those decisions take account of mitigating factors (circumstances that may lessen responsibility). The bill is not law; its passage is uncertain.

  • When deciding whether an individual public-body officer, employee, or member committed a willful and knowing violation, a court would have to consider factors including good-faith reliance on opinions of the Attorney General, court cases, Virginia Freedom of Information Advisory Council opinions, and advice from the public body’s lawyer.
  • When deciding whether to penalize a public body for improperly certifying a closed meeting, a court would have to consider similar reliance factors.
  • The proposed text retains civil penalties for certain willful and knowing violations: $500 to $2,000 for a first violation and $2,000 to $5,000 for a later violation. It also retains a possible penalty of up to $1,000 for a public body’s improper closed-meeting certification.
  • The bill does not establish a new office or program, or change FOIA’s public-records access rules in the text provided.

What it means for you#

  • Public-body officers, employees, and members: If sued individually over a listed FOIA violation, they could point to the listed sources of advice or legal support as mitigating factors. The court would have to consider them, but the bill does not say they automatically excuse a violation.
  • Public bodies: In a case about improper certification of a closed meeting, a court deciding whether to impose a penalty would have to consider specified mitigating factors.
  • People requesting records: The bill does not directly change the rules for requesting or receiving records. It does not create a new complaint or appeal process.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal information is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or set a fee.
  • The proposed text provides for civil penalties paid into Virginia’s Literary Fund. It does not say how many penalties would be imposed or how much revenue they would raise.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended statutes were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which penalty and other provisions are already in force and which are new.
  • The supplied text does not mark additions and deletions in the proposed change to § 2.2-3715. It is therefore unclear whether the bill would replace the existing right to introduce a relevant Advisory Council opinion, or preserve that right while adding the requirement to consider other factors.
  • The bill does not explain how courts should weigh the factors, or whether other factors may also be considered.
  • The supplied material gives no start date or funding details.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make courts consider whether officials relied in good faith on legal or advisory guidance before finding a willful and knowing violation.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that these factors could help distinguish deliberate violations from actions taken after relying on guidance.
  • Requiring courts to consider listed factors may make decisions about individual and public-body penalties more consistent.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not explain how much weight courts should give to advice from a public body’s own lawyer or to cases that only “substantially” support an official’s actions.
  • It is unclear whether the listed factors could reduce the likelihood of a willful-and-knowing finding even when a FOIA violation occurred.
  • Because the supplied text does not show which words are being replaced, readers cannot tell precisely how the proposed rule would differ from current law.