Tests Would Count At Least 10% of Grades

Summary#

HB 189 would amend and reenact Virginia Code § 22.1-253.13:3, a broad section on school accreditation and student assessments. The bill’s stated subject is certain assessment requirements and final course grades; its text would require certain assessment scores to count toward grades and limit how retake scores affect them. The bill has passed the House but is not law, and says it will not take effect unless reenacted by the 2027 General Assembly.

  • For students in grades 7–12, the score on a covered end-of-course assessment must count for at least 10 percent of the final course grade. This applies to Standards of Learning assessments and certain local alternative assessments, but not assessments in a competency-based assessment system.
  • A retake score may not replace the initial score when calculating the final course grade. The text does not say whether a retake score may otherwise be included in that calculation.
  • The bill reproduces many other rules on assessments and accreditation. Because the current version of the amended section was not supplied, it is not possible to verify which of those rules would be new.

What it means for you#

  • Students in grades 7–12: If you take a covered assessment, its score must make up at least 10 percent of your final course grade. If you retake an assessment, the retake score cannot replace your initial score in that grade calculation.
  • Schools and school divisions: They would have to apply the grade-weight and retake rules to covered assessments. The bill does not set out a detailed method for how to calculate grades beyond those requirements.
  • Other students and families: The bill does not directly change eligibility for school, graduation requirements, or access to assessments in the text’s final-grade provisions.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied material includes no cost estimate or fiscal note. It does not identify a specific appropriation for HB 189.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of § 22.1-253.13:3 was not supplied, so the changes from current law cannot be confirmed.
  • The text says the section is effective July 1, 2026, but also says the act will not take effect unless reenacted in 2027. The timing if reenacted is unclear.
  • The bill does not say whether a retake score can count toward a final grade in some way other than replacing the initial score.
  • “Competency-based assessment system” is not defined in the supplied section, though it is an exception to the assessment-timing rule.
  • The bill does not explain how the grade rule interacts with existing local grading policies.

Case for#

  • A required minimum weight could ensure that covered assessments have a meaningful place in final grades rather than being given very little weight.
  • Keeping the initial score from being replaced could preserve a consistent basis for calculating grades across students.
  • The bill sets a statewide rule for the minimum effect of covered assessments on grades.

Case against#

  • A retake score cannot replace the initial score even if it is higher, which could limit how much improvement on a retake affects the final grade.
  • A minimum 10 percent weight may not fit every course or assessment equally well; the bill does not explain how schools should handle that variation.
  • The competency-based exception is not defined in the supplied text, so its scope is unclear.
  • Because the bill rewrites a broad section and the current law was not supplied, readers cannot tell from these materials how much of the text changes existing requirements.