Private Schools Face New Testing Rules

Summary#

HB 359, titled “Private elementary or secondary school; use of public funds for tuition, standards,” would add a new article to the Code of Virginia. It would set requirements for private schools whose students’ tuition is paid partly through covered public tuition-assistance programs or tax-favored education funding; its stated goal is accountability, transparency, and civil-rights protections comparable to those for public schools. The supplied text is a proposed substitute, and the bill is not law.

  • Covered schools would have to test all enrolled students using Virginia Standards of Learning assessments, report results by student subgroup, and reimburse the state for testing costs.
  • Schools would have to meet requirements on admissions, staffing, curriculum, disability services, student discipline, health and safety, financial reporting, and public disclosure.
  • A school with the lowest accountability rating—or one of the two lowest if the rating system has more than three—or that fails accreditation would be barred from enrolling new students using public tuition assistance for five years.
  • The Superintendent could audit and inspect schools and impose penalties, including civil fines of up to $10,000 per violation.
  • The article would not cover certain scholarship programs under Article 13.3 of Title 58.1, or licensed schools for students with disabilities.

What it means for you#

  • Private schools using covered tuition assistance: They would have to meet the article’s requirements to enroll students whose tuition is publicly assisted. Schools already participating on July 1, 2026, would have until July 1, 2027, to comply. Schools joining later would have to comply before enrolling an assisted student.
  • Students and parents at covered schools: The schools’ testing and reporting requirements would apply to all their students, not only students receiving tuition assistance. Parents would be able to inspect instructional materials and request alternative assignments when appropriate. Schools would also have to use written discipline and grievance procedures.
  • Students receiving tuition assistance: Covered schools could not discriminate on the listed grounds, including disability, special education status, language proficiency, or socioeconomic status. A school offering religious instruction or worship would have to provide a nonpunitive opt-out and an alternative activity when a public-assistance student’s parent requests it.
  • Students with disabilities: A covered school could not refuse or withdraw admission from an otherwise qualified student with a disability, and would have to provide services and accommodations at no added charge. The article separately excludes licensed schools for students with disabilities.
  • Teachers and school staff: Teachers in core subjects would need a Virginia license or an equivalent credential approved by the Board. Administrators and counselors would need qualifications set by the Board.
  • Taxpayers: The bill would not create a tuition-assistance program or change taxes. It would regulate schools connected to specified funding arrangements; schools would not be required by this bill to accept public assistance.

Money#

The bill gives no estimate of public costs or savings.

  • Covered schools would have to repay the Department the full cost of testing their students. The Superintendent would set a per-student rate, and the Department would provide cost estimates on request.
  • Schools would have to pay for audits of their own financial statements and meet other compliance requirements. The bill gives no estimate of those costs.
  • The Department would have to provide technical assistance and publish school reports and assessment results. The bill does not state the staffing or cost required.
  • The Superintendent could impose fines of up to $10,000 per violation and require repayment of misused public funds.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of the Code provisions being added to, so existing-law overlap could not be checked.
  • The Board would create or approve ratings, qualifications, and equivalent academic standards. The bill does not specify how these would work or how schools would be assessed.
  • The bill does not set out how schools may challenge an accountability rating or accreditation failure, apart from an appeal process for penalties.
  • “Extraordinary circumstances” for a tuition-increase waiver is illustrated but not fully defined. The bill also does not explain how the Board would decide waiver requests.
  • The text gives a compliance deadline but no general start date. It also does not explain how requirements would apply if a funding arrangement falls partly outside the article under federal law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to attach public accountability and student protections to private-school enrollment supported by public funding or tax advantages.
  • Requiring public assessments and subgroup reporting could make academic results more visible to families and the public.
  • Financial statements, tuition schedules, and contract disclosures could give the public more information about how participating schools use their money.
  • Common rules for admissions, disability services, and student complaints could give students and families clearer protections at covered schools.

Case against#

  • The requirements apply broadly within participating schools: testing, for example, covers every enrolled student, even if only some students receive tuition assistance.
  • The five-year bar on new assisted enrollment could continue even if a school’s rating later improves; the Board’s rules for rating and re-entry are not fully specified.
  • Testing reimbursements, audits, staffing standards, and other compliance duties could impose costs on schools, but the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • The bill leaves important implementation choices to the Board and Department, including ratings, qualifications, and reporting details.
  • The religious-school provisions preserve religious instruction and some employment practices while also imposing nondiscrimination and opt-out duties. How these rules interact in particular cases is not explained.