Alternative Tests for Some Students With Disabilities

Summary#

HB 1410, “Certain student assessment requirements; exception for certain students with disabilities,” is an introduced bill to amend and reenact a section of Virginia’s Standards of Quality law on school accreditation and student assessments. Its stated subject is an exception to some assessment requirements for certain students with disabilities. The supplied bill restates the full section without showing edits, and the current law is not supplied, so it is not possible to verify exactly what the bill would change.

  • The text says the Board of Education sets criteria for students with disabilities to use alternative methods of Standards of Learning assessment.
  • For a student who qualifies, the student’s Individual Education Program (IEP) team makes the final decision on whether an alternative method is appropriate.
  • The assessment rules for grades 3–8 and 9–12 exclude students who participate in an alternative assessment under that provision. This is not a blanket exemption from testing: the text provides for an alternative assessment method.
  • The bill does not set out an application process, timelines, or appeal rules for this decision.
  • The bill is introduced and is not law. The supplied status says it was continued from the prior session.

What it means for you#

  • Students with disabilities and families: The text provides for an alternative assessment method for students who meet Board criteria. An IEP team decides whether it is appropriate for an eligible student. The text does not say that every student with a disability qualifies or is excused from assessment.
  • IEP teams: They make the final determination about whether an alternative method is appropriate for an eligible student.
  • The Board of Education: It sets the eligibility criteria and prescribes alternative assessment methods.
  • Schools and school divisions: The assessment rules described in the bill do not apply to students who participate in the specified alternative assessment. The supplied text does not establish how schools would identify eligible students or carry out the process.
  • Other students and the public: The bill text does not directly change graduation requirements, assessment rules for students outside this exception, or school accreditation rules—but the missing current law means the exact changes cannot be confirmed.

Money#

No cost information is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill text contains no specific appropriation or cost estimate.
  • It refers to assessment work being done with funds available for that purpose, but the supplied material does not show whether this bill would add costs or require new staff.

What is unclear#

  • Which wording is new: the supplied text restates the whole law without marking changes, and the current law was not provided.
  • What criteria the Board would use to decide which students qualify. The text refers to Board criteria but does not include them.
  • What “alternative method” means in practice, including how a student’s assessment would be administered and scored.
  • How families would raise concerns or challenge an eligibility or assessment decision.
  • The text refers to the legal definition of “children with disabilities,” but that definition was not supplied for comparison.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that an alternative assessment method can allow eligible students with disabilities to demonstrate learning in a way their IEP team considers appropriate.
  • The text gives the IEP team the final decision, which places that decision with the team responsible for the student’s education plan.
  • The text still provides for assessment; it does not describe a general exemption from measuring student learning.

Case against#

  • The supplied bill copy does not show what is actually changing, so readers cannot tell whether the stated exception is new or already part of the law.
  • The Board’s eligibility criteria and the details of alternative methods are not included, leaving the practical scope of the exception unclear.
  • The text does not explain how families can question a decision or how schools should apply the criteria consistently.