Printed Textbook Pilot Targets 10 Divisions

Summary#

HB 362 would add a section to the Code of Virginia to establish a Printed Textbook Pilot Program. Its stated goal is to promote positive educational outcomes by making printed textbooks and other high-quality instructional materials the primary curriculum basis for students in participating school divisions. The bill is introduced and is not law; whether it passes is uncertain.

  • The Department must select up to 10 school divisions through a competitive process. It may consider school and division performance, enrollment and student demographics, and geographic diversity.
  • In participating divisions, printed textbooks and other high-quality instructional materials must be the primary curriculum basis for each student, unless the student’s individualized education program indicates otherwise.
  • The Department must provide technical assistance on choosing materials if a participating division asks for it.
  • The Department must award grants to participating divisions, but only with funds appropriated for that purpose. Grants cannot require a local match and must add to, not replace, other state funds for textbooks provided at no cost to students.
  • The Department must report each year by November 1 on implementation, satisfaction, and student learning and outcomes.

What it means for you#

  • Participating school divisions: Selected divisions would have to make printed textbooks and other high-quality instructional materials the primary curriculum basis for each enrolled student, subject to the exception for a student’s individualized education program. They could ask the Department for help choosing materials and would help provide information for the annual report.
  • Students and families: The bill does not require families to pay for textbooks. It says grants must supplement state funds for textbooks provided at no cost to students. The bill does not explain the details of that existing funding.
  • Other school divisions: The bill does not require every division to join. It sets a competitive pilot of up to 10 divisions.
  • Taxpayers: The bill makes grants dependent on appropriations, but does not set an amount.

Money#

The bill makes grant spending conditional on an appropriation and gives no cost estimate.

  • The Department must award grants if funds are appropriated for the pilot. The bill states no total, per-division amount, or duration for the grants.
  • The Department must administer the program and produce annual reports. No staffing or administrative cost estimate is provided.
  • Grants cannot require a local match and cannot replace other state funds provided for textbooks at no cost to students.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “high-quality” or explain what it means for printed materials to be the “primary curriculum basis.”
  • It gives the Department power to set timelines, forms, policies, processes, and rules, but does not set application details, selection standards, or a start or end date.
  • The bill does not specify how much funding each division would receive or what happens if appropriations are insufficient.
  • It does not explain how the pilot interacts with other textbook funding or programs.
  • The bill requires annual reports but does not set measures for student learning or explain how the reported information would be used.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives participating divisions a clear priority—printed textbooks and other high-quality materials—while allowing a student’s individualized education program to indicate otherwise.
  • A competitive pilot of up to 10 divisions could let the state gather information on implementation, satisfaction, and student outcomes before deciding whether to modify or expand the program.
  • Grants with no local-match requirement could let selected divisions take part without requiring them to contribute matching funds.

Case against#

  • One concern is that requiring printed materials to be the primary basis for instruction could limit divisions’ flexibility, while the bill does not define how to judge material quality or what “primary” means in practice.
  • The bill leaves key choices—including selection rules, timelines, and grant amounts—to the Department, with few standards in the text.
  • The pilot requires state funding and administrative work, but the bill gives no cost estimate or funding guarantee.