20% Earned Income Credit for Two Years

Summary#

HB 372, titled “Income tax, state; removes sunset from and makes permanent increase in refundable earned tax credit,” would amend Virginia Code § 58.1-339.8. Its stated goal is to make the increased refundable earned income tax credit permanent. But the supplied bill text still limits the 20% credit to tax years beginning in 2025 or 2026; it does not show the credit continuing after 2026.

  • For those two tax years, an individual or married couple could claim a refundable Virginia credit equal to 20% of the federal earned income tax credit claimed.
  • The bill says the credit must be claimed on the Virginia income tax return and redeemed by the Tax Commissioner.
  • A household could not claim this credit in the same year as either of the other two credits described in the bill: a $300-per-person nonrefundable credit or a nonrefundable credit equal to 20% of the federal credit.
  • The bill bars the credits if the taxpayer, spouse, or a dependent claims any of five specified Virginia tax subtractions or deductions.
  • The bill is introduced, not law. The supplied text does not include the current version of the amended section, so it is not possible to verify how much of its wording would change current law.

What it means for you#

  • Taxpayers claiming the federal earned income tax credit: If enacted as written, you could claim the 20% Virginia credit for tax years 2025 and 2026, instead of the other credits listed in the bill. The text does not clearly state a separate eligibility test for this 20% credit beyond calculating it from the federal credit claimed.
  • Taxpayers with little or no Virginia income tax liability: The credit is refundable, so it can exceed the tax you owe. However, the bill caps the credit at your Virginia tax liability if you are a nonresident or are covered by the specified nonresident tax rule.
  • Taxpayers, spouses, and dependents claiming specified tax benefits: Any one of five listed subtractions or deductions would make the household ineligible for the credits in this section. The supplied material does not explain what those five tax benefits cover.
  • Other taxpayers: The bill does not create a new application process or change the federal earned income tax credit.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.

  • Refunds could exceed Virginia income tax owed for eligible taxpayers who are not subject to the bill’s liability cap; the materials give no estimate of the resulting state cost or revenue effect.
  • The bill does not state how many people would claim the credit or how large claims might be.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s title says the increase would be made permanent, but its text limits the 20% credit to tax years before January 1, 2027.
  • The current version of the amended Virginia Code section was not supplied, so the exact change from current law cannot be confirmed.
  • The text does not explain how the five listed tax subtractions and deductions affect eligibility in practical terms.
  • No cost estimate, later-year funding information, or other implementation details are provided.
  • The bill is introduced, so whether it will pass is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A refundable credit can benefit eligible taxpayers even when their Virginia income tax bill is smaller than the credit.
  • Using a share of the federal earned income tax credit provides a way to calculate the state credit from an amount already claimed on a federal return.
  • A possible argument for making the increase permanent is that eligible taxpayers would not face an end date—but the supplied operative text does not carry out that stated goal.

Case against#

  • The mismatch between the stated goal and the text leaves unclear whether the 20% credit would end after 2026.
  • The bill provides no cost estimate, so the public cost of refunds cannot be assessed from the supplied material.
  • The listed tax-benefit exclusions could make eligibility difficult to understand; the bill does not explain why those benefits disqualify a household.